Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

Some interesting history, thoughts, and ideas re UCs and testing here (it isn’t all anti-testing):

UC could go back to using the SAT and ACT for admissions. Here’s why that doesn’t add up

https://archive.ph/jZNZZ

I agree there’s a pretty massive disconnect between what thousands of professors are seeing in terms of student preparedness vs final results. I think it’s worth investigating what happened to GPA in colleges distributions post-covid.

And the lack of preparedness is not limited to just UCSD either. Here’s a Berkeley math professor saying that calculus classes there have students who also don’t understand basic mathematics:

Placing unprepared students in the same classroom as prepared ones puts brakes on the entire class. Our UC Berkeley calculus classes now have to pause to explain basic properties of addition and multiplication — for example, that (a+b) c = ac + bc. According to California’s Common Core standards, this material is taught in third grade.

The students most hurt are those the policy was supposed to help — first-generation, low-income and underrepresented students. Hiding preparation gaps does not remove them; it shifts them to the classroom, where they become harder to overcome. While weaker students drown in material they were never prepared to learn, stronger students tune out.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/06/30/california-stopped-requiring-sat-now-students-struggle-with-fractions/

1 Like

This article was a disappointment because it contained the following:

Saul Geiser, a UC Berkeley professor and a top expert on this issue, says the task force report was flawed because it failed to account for factors including family income and parent education.

There’s two levels of incompetence here. First, because Saul Geiser clearly never read the report, as I showed tables and graphs above from that report that controlled for family income, and there are others in the report that control for parental education. Second, because the author also clearly has not read the report and therefore didn’t call out Saul on his error.

1 Like

To maintain the quality of this space, please ensure your contributions are directly relevant to where our two main topics - universities and standardized testing - meet. Off-topic posts will be removed without comment. To keep the feed clean, we also ask that you avoid posting public grievances or questioning moderation actions; these meta-posts will also be deleted.

1 Like

I rephrased my post with a greater focus on standardized testing at UCs. If this is not acceptable, feel free to delete.

UCs required standardized testing in 2019, then switched to test blind beginning in fall 2021. One concern about this switch from requiring tests in 2019 to not requiring tests in 2021+ is enrolling a larger portion of students who don’t meet basic math qualifications due to not requiring tests. One way to estimate this portion that do not meet basic math qualifications is to look at math placement test results and corresponding math enrollment – how has the portion of students placing at below calculus level changed from when test were required in 2019 to when test blind in 2021+.

The changes in pre-calc enrollment vary wildly at different UCs, rather than being a pattern of all UCs show the same type of change following the switch from from test required to test blind. For example, UCLA and UCSB saw little change in pre-calculus enrollment when switching from test required to test blind, UCI and UCSC saw large increases, and UCM saw a large decrease. The table below shows how math enrollment has changed at UCB since switching from test required to test blind. Prior to adding math 1, the percent in pre-calc was 8% while test required, 9% when test blind in 2021, and 10%when test blind in 2022. Yes, that’s an increase, but it’s a different order of magnitude of increase than UCSD. UCSD is indeed unique.

There are tens of thousands of faculty in UC system, so the thousands who signed the document saying they supported switching from test blind back to test required is not a majority of faculty. I would not assume that all of those thousands signed because they personally saw a severe math (or other subject) deficiency compare to previous years that they believe is due to switching from test required to test blind. I expect many signed largely for other reasons such as being concerned by the UCSD math report, being influenced by recent standardized testing decisions of Ivy+ type colleges, or generally being in favor of test required over test blind.

3 Likes

Commentary: UC could go back to using the SAT and ACT for admissions. Here's why that doesn't add up is the original page without going through a dodgy archive site, if it doesn’t paywall you.

Thanks for making the article available. The author supports bringing back test requirements for admissions—but not the SAT. She thinks California can design or offer better tests. But she doesn’t say which ones are better or how they can be designed. This sounds like making a theoretically better test be the enemy of what is actually possible now.

What about AP testing? Or is that “unfair “ because not everyone gets to do AP?

1 Like

Paywalled for me.

There aren’t currently any better standardized tests than the SAT or ACT. The only other one that has any traction (and it’s not much) in the US is CLT. It’s easy to find fault with CollegeBoard and ACT (now owned by ETS) but the reality is they have spent millions of dollars improving the tests, shortening them, developing digital offerings, increasing security. It’s a heavy lift.

Any new test is likely going to have similar issues to the SAT/ACT. There has been some talk about the UCs using CAASPP but that’s not perfect, nor do OOS/international students have access to that.

As far as AP tests, it’s a huge access issue as well as monetary issue. Not to mention many schools limit AP classes until junior and senior years and senior year AP test results obviously aren’t available for application season.

There are some data for APs (and DE) in CA here: Equitable Access to Rigorous High School Coursework: Nationwide vs California | The Campaign for College Opportunity

3 Likes

Thanks for that data. It highlighted the correlation between standardized testing availability and disparities in educational opportunities. The UC professors advocating a return to test required are dealing with the tail end of this problem; I really think it is a poor use of their resources to dump this problem on them.

… in the US for college admission.

However, their target market is the mainstream of colleges and their applicants, not the top end colleges and their applicants, hence the ceiling effect that limits their usefulness in the latter case (even though high school grade inflation has made the ceiling effect even worse for high school GPA).

Other countries’ standardized tests are also more achievement oriented than the SAT and ACT. The US equivalent would be something like the discontinued SAT subject tests for ordinary level material and AP tests for advanced level material.

Some countries include standardized achievement testing as part (or all) of high school course grades, so external standardized tests are not needed for domestic applicants. But there would be resistance to that in the US due to “local control of education” and the like.

That would be really hard to require unless it becomes easy to sign up for, which it is NOT.

If your school doesn’t offer it, accessing a test isn’t simple at all is what I have heard/been told by many. (and MANY schools do not offer it).

1 Like

Just as a different view, as we discuss the UC study, we should also consider this study from the Chicago Public Schools. The data is also different - these are test score average and GPA averages across schools. Like the study I criticized, these graphs also do not show variation around the mean. There is also a lot more information in these graphs that really should be explored.

High School GPAs and ACT Scores as Predictors of College Completion: Examining Assumptions About Consistency Across High Schools

1 Like

Vanderbilt to end its test-optional policy and require ACT or SAT for Class of 2029.

3 Likes

I am surprised, only because V seemed to be a school that had fully embraced TO. There are very few left in the top 20 who are TO; I think a couple more are going to flip soon.

3 Likes

Duke next?

Wonder if Vanderbilt felt like they were getting too many uncompetitive apps and wanted to do some culling for their AO.

4 Likes

To be honest, it is rather embarrassing they have not ended TO already. The longtime admissions chair retired, thus the interim situation could be why. I have no knowledge at all. I expect it will change back soon.

2 Likes

Notre Dame to require test scores for HS Class of 2028:

2 Likes

Interesting that Notre Dame (and others) will require SAT or ACT for transfer applicants, some of whom may not have taken either test while in high school, or may have taken a test long ago (non traditional students).

2 Likes