<p>See second portion of previous post. Selectivity by admissions % doesn’t automatically equate to student quality, nor does it provide a full picture of selectivity. CalTech and U Chicago for example. Stanford will always have a very low admissions rating. On top of being an amazing school, there are fewer schools of its caliber on the west coast.</p>
<p>To not lose track of the argument, admitted and enrolled Columbia students are in line with Stanford students and other top schools. Suggesting that Columbia ED is for applicants who do not have a reasonable chance at other schools is simply not accurate because these students have a reasonable chance at all top schools. Columbia offers a unique environment and is the first choice for many students. Just as Stanford offers a great environment and is the first choice for many. Stanford is not simply for students who don’t think they can get into Harvard for instance.</p>