I would suggest Wooster as well. Max academic merit last year was 37k and could be stacked with performing arts scholarships for an extra couple of thousand $. The performing arts scholarships only require an extracurricular commitment.
I would describe the student body as passionate and a little quirky. Lots of performance and community service opportunities. The town of Wooster has a really nice downtown with coffee shops and restaurants about a mile from campus.
Academically, there is a big emphasis on mentored research; each student has to complete an original research project senior year. The new science building is gorgeous! Grad school placement rates are outstanding.
My D ended up at Wooster as her 1st choice, but other schools on her radar were St Olaf, Lawrence, Clark, CWRU and Grinnell.
Theses are not LAC but to me they have that feel, Rice and WPI. They are very different but they may be worth a look. Also, if she is interested in women’s college, there is Bryn Mare, Mt Holyoke and agnes scott.
@collegemom3717@cinnamon1212 Thanks! I like W&L too… but then I’m the southerner in this family so no surprise there. Ha! My D’s dad is from the EU.
I think I answered the questions about why there were only southern and great lakes schools on her narrowed down list at the moment… the ones she has actually visited. She has a much longer “watch” list she is trying to narrow down… and that is correct, Oberlin hasn’t been cut from it yet!
@collegemom3717 Your comment about going from a small elite private to a large public univ is definitely a consideration for us and one we have talked about a good bit. HC will help a bit, but it will be a completely different experience from a LAC. Lots to talk through and weigh out.
As many of you have mentioned, W&L in general is more conservative than my D (some other southern schools too). She has been diving into that more and how much that will weigh in her decision to apply vs the things she likes about it. She supports the renaming of W&L, although that is a concern for some of her classmates and may keep them from applying. She is used to being a liberal kid in a more conservative environment so perhaps looks at it a bit differently from someone living in a different part of the country.
We do not qualify for need based aid.
To Everyone - please keep those comments coming. Your perspectives are so helpful and have given me pause to really think about topics we should discuss in more detail as a family. There are so many considerations it is easy to get lost in just the stats or the beautiful architecture or whatever when there is so much more to finding the right fit.
Someone mentioned St. Olaf, and I agree that it seems like it might be a good fit for your daughter, and they are likely to offer good merit to someone with her stats. Carleton is in the same town, but I am not sure whether they offer merit. Macalester is also pretty close by.
@DramaMama2021 – My D18 is a bio major at Davidson and I think your D would fit very well there based on your description. Excellent and large bio and chem departments. Left leaning, though all viewpoints represented. It’s not as conservative as W&L by any means.
Merit $$ there is hard to come by, but we were surprised and got some $$ there as a fin aid bubble family. While other colleges like Carleton, basically just offered work/study and loans, Davidson granted her $15k a year which put it in range for us. She was NMF and the grant seems to be a gray area between need and merit. She ended up passing on bigger merit awards at Grinnell, Mt. Holyoke and Scripps to attend Davidson b/c she fell in love with it.
I think of Rhodes and Richmond as similar to Davidson but more likely to get money. Agree with Grinnell, Mt. Holyoke and WPI as good merit opportunities for your D. but she needs to start showing interest now, if she hasn’t already. Case possibly too but they are dialing back their merit these days, I think, compared to a few years ago.
Furman also has some great merit and I bet she’d be strong candidate. Strong in sciences too.
My overall point is we didn’t expect Davidson to be financially in range for us but they surprised us so keep them in the mix!
I’m going back to your original description of what your D is looking for. I too do not feel that most of the schools you listed fit the idea of a northern liberal leaning LAC.
If merit is needed, I second or third Dickinson and Muhlenberg. I also think she could consider Susquehanna and Juniata.
Union in NY could work. I believe Skidmore still has some merit scholarships, and it’s probably more prestigious than some of the others. Definitely consider Conn College and Trinity. I’d say both Union and Trinity are a little more conservative.
Outside the Northeast, there are some really great choices in the Midwest, as already mentioned. Kenyon could be an great choice, but it’s few merit scholarships are extremely selective. Amazing school though.
I think your D would qualify for the highest scholarship at Whitman, which is in Walla Walla, WA. Great school, very happy students (often voted so in Princeton Review), liberal but not too lefty, lovely campus, excellent profs and academics.
If she is open to Catholic schools Providence College is generous with merit for high stats students, as is Fairfield. Some of the state schools such as UMass, Univ Maryland, Univ Delaware have honors programs that may also offer merit to an OOS student. As a parent of a college student who insisted she was interested in medical school, I would suggest that you make sure the school has other majors she may be interested in if she decides against med school (as mine did).
And, you probably know this already, but at the more selective schools it will also be more competitive to participate in activities that are important for med school applications - relevant volunteer work in hospital, research, etc. Sometimes a less competitive school where your daughter has a chance to really stand out will make it easier for her to be selected for those important extracurriculars.
Would it be a problem if fraternity / sorority life is dominant, like at W&L?
Medical schools can be $400k for four years these days. In-state public may be somewhat less, but most medical school applicants get no admissions, and most who do get admitted get admitted to one, so they have no opportunity to choose a less expensive one.