Pride goes before destruction, and a haughty spirit before stumbling. It is better to be humble in spirit with the lowly than to divide the spoil with the proud. (Proverbs 16: 18)
Let’s just quit arguing.
Pride goes before destruction, and a haughty spirit before stumbling. It is better to be humble in spirit with the lowly than to divide the spoil with the proud. (Proverbs 16: 18)
Let’s just quit arguing.
Well, I can only make a guess . .
The reality is that more 60% of Harvard families are on financial aid, and while they can apply for financial aid for international summer study programs, it still cost’s about $5K, not including airfare to send your kid overseas for the summer. That’s not something our family could afford. Instead, my kids worked during the summer to earn money for college.
whoa: now you realize that this Proverb is one you quote to yourself-- and is not meant to be a cudgel to someone else right? Because it sure seems like you’re directing that at Gibby rather than yourself.
Maybe the replies here have been a little more blunt than you anticipated but we’re not here to needlessly pour cold water on you – but to guide you based on your content and tone. For those who have been on CC for a bit (and especially the H forum – which seems to be a magnet for this type of post), we’ve seen many proud and stubborn come and state their assured pathway to getting admitted to H, no matter what.
I meant it for all of us.
To be honest @T26E4, I came here just to hear how could I improve on my chances. Instead, I received posts such as:
-“It’s just foolish, IMHO. You’ll serve yourself much better if you aim to be the best you can be, eventually targeting a broad list of (hopefully) “elite” colleges.”
-“The GPA cut-off is 3.5. How many kids at your school have a 3.5 GPA? That’s how (non) selective the program really is.”
-“Looks like this kid’s family was trying to buy him awards.”
-“National Society of High School Scholars – you can omit that one too. It’s another vanity money-making venture”
I personally felt that you were putting me down instead of helping me. Look, I’m just a young kid with hopes and dreams just like all these other kids in CC. Don’t take it as an insult. It is my honest opinion. Don’t forget: we are only teenagers.
@1LuckyBrave you asked
and they gave you their honest opinion.
From the NY Times:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/04/19/education/edlife/leadership-t.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
I think you’ve gotten solid advice here, but if you’re seeking encouragement and affirmation, you might try posting here: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/what-my-chances/
Like I said in post 22, I see that the replies were more blunt than you anticipated. But plz allow me to expand further:
-“It’s just foolish, IMHO. You’ll serve yourself much better if you aim to be the best you can be, eventually targeting a broad list of (hopefully) “elite” colleges.”
I stand by this 100% will repeat that you should aim to improve yourself to be the best possible son or daughter/student/scholar/community member you should be – not simply as a future applicant of college A or college B. My experience is that laser-beam focused kids on Harvard or Stanford or Princeton et al are commonplace but never admitted. Because their goals are so narrow and based upon what they perceive as formulae – rather than being authentic. It’s akin to saying you wish to play for the Denver Broncos while you’re just a high school JV football player. Sincerely, if you aspire to top colleges, reach for the stars – a top college diploma is just a blip on that trajectory. If all you’re doing is looking for an Ivy diploma, then your aiming too low (and consequently, will miss the Ivy too).
-“The GPA cut-off is 3.5. How many kids at your school have a 3.5 GPA? That’s how (non) selective the program really is.”
I understand that Future Physicians was a great program for you and that’s a great thing and I’m not trying to diminish that. Like I said before, that seems to be the general consensus. However, I wanted to counter what you believe (and what Envision LMI espouses) is the unique nature of the selection process. It’s very general and that’s plain. It’s a money making venture. If anyone can submit a paid registration, they are accepted.
-“Looks like this kid’s family was trying to buy him awards.”
An unfortunate reality in the admissions rat race. This thought permeates selective college admissions officers b/c of the emergence of many manyjunkets that market themselves to parents and kids who feel that this will “make them look unique” and dedicated and to be a game-changer on the resume/EC list. Since the “nomination” process is so loose and the “acceptance” criteria is a check that clears, the “award” of NSHSS or Future Physicians or Future Leaders is not much of one.
-“National Society of High School Scholars – you can omit that one too. It’s another vanity money-making venture”
Self evident. Do the research and you’ll find out how “exclusive” this pay-to-join club really is.
@1LuckyBrave,
Although some students may be going for humanitarian relief efforts, my own take is that most are going for study and research opportunities. And even those going for humanitarian purposes are often actually conducting research or study in their fields at the same time. One of my older son’s friends spent time in Africa one semester assisting communities in dealing with AIDS. But the primary driver of the trip was medical research.
“1000/6400 does NOT add up to be 60%,…”
A thousand students per year adds up. Sixty percent isn’t unbelievable.
“The reality is that more 60% of Harvard families are on financial aid, and while they can apply for financial aid for international summer study programs, it still cost’s about $5K, not including airfare to send your kid overseas for the summer.”
A lot of opportunities are partially or completely-funded. My son spent a J-term in Greece one year. I had to contribute a few hundred bucks for his airfare to Athens. Harvard paid a lump sum for airfare over to Greece, and then all in-country travel, all food and lodging was paid by Harvard. But no humanitarian stuff. Just study.
This coming summer, my son will be in Asia. All paid for by Harvard. The one sticking point will be that he won’t have any opportunity to work for wages this summer, and thus, will not be able to earn all his “self-help” money this year. I’ve asked him to talk to the financial aid folks about reducing that part of his package (which would then increase his financial aid by a like amount). We’ll have to see how that goes.
But, it’s a research opportunity (not humanitarian) in his concentration, so we’ll figure out a way to make it happen, no matter what.
Thank you for your responses and wisdom. This is most likely my last post (school’s back, books are out). My last question up for everyone is how did your children manage their time to (1) keep up grades 4.4+, (2) study for SAT/ACT, (3) participate sports and ECs, and (4) enjoy their social life. Being a dedicated scholar, I notice it is a different case for me as well as my friends compared to the “average” teen.
Hello @arwarw,
I wasn’t happy with the responses, because it was not what I was looking for (and I personally felt down at first). Being a sophomore, I still have 2 years to build my resume. Some critical parts of my timeline are coming up: SAT, ACT, PSATs, AP Tests, prom, etc. I was yearning to find an answer on how to fight against the struggle. In addition, I wanted to know if my E.C.s looked dedicated and consistent. However, I wasn’t really specific when I created the thread, because it was my first post.
Actually, being a sophomore, you have 1 year to build your resume, as SCEA applicants apply prior to November 1st of their senior year, and RD applicants apply prior to January 1st of their senior year. So, whatever you have accomplished by the end of your junior year is basically what colleges see before they pass judgement on you.
That’s very true, and without those scores, it’s really too early to ask for chances.
As you never indicated in your initial post how many years you’ve been involved with each activity, that’s kind of impossible for anyone to answer. College’s look for student’s to make a long term commitment to an activity – one to three years. Based upon your initial post . . .
. . . There really isn’t anything there that indicates your long term commitment (maybe there is, but you didn’t write it down that way), nor is there anything that distinguishes you from other students who have similar interests. See: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/marjorie-hansen-shaevitz/extra-curricular-activities-college-admission_b_3040217.html
If you’re thinking of applying to Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford or MIT, you have to ask yourself "What makes me unique? What makes me a “oner?” What do I have that other students do not? After all, these are the top colleges in the country – schools that have recruited the likes of Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Yo-Yo Ma – and who have rejected the likes of Warren Buffet et al. See: http://abcnews.go.com/US/story?id=3201481
If you can’t answer that question, your resume is going to be too similar to hundreds of other students with top GPA’s and test scores, so you are not going to be able to stand out from the crowd and will most likely get buried by the competition. See: http://www.businessinsider.com/most-impressive-harvard-students-2012-11
When you can say that you do not really need a university to achieve your goals since you are on a great trajectory- you are noticed at a city-wide, state-wide, nation-wide, or international level, you have plans and are pursuing your passion to make the world (or some corner of it) a better place; but that the college (e.g. Harvard) could accelerate your life purpose in some specific tangible way, then you can feel more assured of being accepted. This is what your real-world mentors mean when they say to expand your passions- they mean not to increase the number, but the intensity and impact. That is also what is meant by @T26E4 when s/he says:
That could be tennis or boxing (can you enhance Harvard’s team?), or it could be some other endeavor. Being a participant in a leadership conference is plain-vanilla. Continuing a relationship with an ex-physician to the president, to a former surgeon-general, or to an Ebola survivor (whom you met at said opportunity) and collaborating on an impactful initiative- that is passion in action. You have been given access to these people, how will you leverage these opportunities? How will you make your way in this world? Universities are truly looking at how you leverage the cards you are dealt. You have been dealt some winning hands. You have had the personal contact and connection. Presumably, you have the email addresses. What is it YOU will do with that raw material? Depth of a passion is much more important than multiple passions (third after grades, then test scores, of course). You can see how these opportunities are double-edged swords. Tell Harvard you went, and they now know you had opportunity- what did you do with that opportunity- that is the key question.
If you are working on, say, a nationwide smoking-cessation initiative that you started with an ex-surgeon-general, you may feel the urge to take time off from college to pursue this passion. You don’t need Harvard to take your next step, but attending Harvard may accelerate it. If you are qualified and can handle the academics, why would they then not take you?
Note, this is way overboard and not necessary to acceptance- but certainly a good target to form your ambitions as a Sophomore on how to be irresistible! It gives you a framework for the mindset that (I think) you are seeking.
@1LuckyBrave,
You’re welcome.
My children just worked hard academically. Three hours of homework per night wasn’t unusual. Inch by inch, life’s a cinch. Yard by yard, life is hard.
Although they got very good grades, neither had an unweighted GPA of 4.0. It just wasn’t a goal. They just did their best. They were more interested in learning what they wanted to learn, not the grades they got. Of course, when you’re learning what you want to learn, grades of A seem to come more readily. By their sophomore year, each one had pretty much wrested control of their respective curriculum away from the school administration.and shaped their own path forward. They fulfilled certain school curricular requirements, then did what they wanted to do.
They didn’t do much prep for the SAT. My younger son went to a class on Saturdays for a few weeks, but his practice test scores kept declining, so he told me he thought it messed with his own test-taking system, and I didn’t make him go after that. Both my sons did very well on the SAT. They studied a bit for AP and SAT II exams, but mostly, they just did their work.
“I was yearning to find an answer on how to fight against the struggle. In addition,…”
Like the commercial says, “Just do it.”
Both my sons are pretty much academically-inclined. They had no really spectacular extracurriculars, they weren’t in sports. Non-academic activities often revolved around academic activities for them. They enjoyed things like quiz bowl, chess club, math club, science club. They tutored other students. They served the school by helping to lead academic events for local middle schools held at the high school.
Neither of my sons had an extremely active social life. No time! But they had friends, went to events that they enjoyed. My older son dated a college girl his junior year of high school, and found time for that.