The liberal arts division of Purchase College represents, by design, the basic model you appear to be seeking. As an indication of this, it may be the only SUNY ranked by U.S. News in the National Liberal Arts category. In terms of your daughter’s academic interests, history, for example, is a popular major there; and Purchase recently graduated more philosophy majors than Williams.
One drawback might be a surburban location in which the college isn’t a prominent driver of a local atmosphere of particular interest to college students. The importance of this might depend on how often your daughter seeks out the attractions of Manhattan.
Considering Purchase College in a very general, statistical sense, its acceptance rate of 75% may indicate a somewhat academically varied student body in the classroom.