<p>Actually, her question is valid. There has been so much different information regarding his past, that perhaps she was asking for clarification, or to get kids thinking. You do NOT have to be born in the US to be a natural born citizen. You may be born overseas under certain circumstances and meet the criteria. Many people heard he lived in Indonesia, etc. I checked his website and it mentions he was born on the date, but not where, and never mentions Indonesia. Other sites mention born in Hawaii and living in Indonesia.</p>