<p>tokenadult
</p>
<p>Ouch. I did not mean to endorse the list in any way, it just happened I knew what the OP asked about (or it seemsd I knew). I also don’t like the Mathews rankings (just discussed them again somewhere: probably, Newsweek published a fresh list, so they are being discussed again).</p>
<p>Well, just to add to the collection: the most (ahem… strange?) criterion I’ve ever seen was used by Worth magazine, it rated the schools by the acceptances to HYP only. In comparison, the WSJ list makes more sense… :)</p>