Well, no maybe not that life, but that was his choice. And while he may not have felt he gave what he should have, he did give Ellie her life back, and in my book that counts for a lot. And I’d like to think that he knows that when he sees her. I loved the scene in the lecture hall where he stands up for her and then slips out the door, because it echoed the way he slipped out of her life before, but then he comes back and actually makes things really right.