Thoughts on these pre-med programs?

I think that one of the reasons that people have given such a range of answers is that your question is not as simple as it may seem. When you say ‘rank these pre-med programs’ do you mean 'rank the best quality pre-med coursework or ‘rank which ones get more students into med school’ or ‘rank which ones give the best pre-med counseling/support’?

For best quality pre-med coursework, all of the schools on your list are comparable, as they are all academically solid for those courses, so ranking is not meaningful.

For which ones get more students into med school, it is hard to rank for you, partly because it is very hard to compare med school success rates b/c the way different colleges count that can be so skewed and partly because we don’t know enough about you. For example, I would put Emory, Vanderbilt, GW and CW as a first tier amongst your list- if you are in the top 15-20% of your (university) class. But you would have to know (for example) if the kind of pre-professional competitive vibe at Emory would be a plus for you: there are students for whom that environment would be counterproductive. That’s where all the comments about ‘go where you will shine’ come in.

If you mean which ones give the best pre-med counseling/support, I am not great on the colleges you list- but there are others who can speak to that specific metric (most of the colleges who pre-med support I know much about are LACs). You might be best off going to the forums for your favorite two or three colleges and asking the specific question on those forums “how is the pre-med counseling/support at this university”?