Correct, and he received opinions based on the stats he provided because he asked for them. As most responders have said, no one can tell him if it will work or not, only offer their opinions, which is what he posted for in the first place.
He seems perfectly able to advocate for himself thus far, and not really in need of defending, as what has been presented are only the opinions he requested. Your frustration seems misplaced, but best of luck to you in your transfer group and your own efforts to do the same.