UC Berkeley Portal Astrology Discussion 2023

hmm yeah, i did some lurking and this situation seems eerily similar to last year - but still trying to have hope

Got not authorized: UCLA accept, UCSD accept

(also UVA, UNC, UT-Austin accept)

it isn’t really, though. last year and all the years before that had a really strong reliability with the withdraw page. this one has questionable reliability with a page that seems to display different results depending on your method of accessing it

1 Like

i’m not authorized and have these results so far
accepted: ucsd, ucr, ucsc, ucd
rejected: uci
waitlisted: ucsb and ucla

1 Like

oh also @yagawawa there seems to be an incongruity with the appeals page access

1 Like

oh? elaborate?

because everyone ive asked with not authorized can see something like

ā€œThis is only accessible to those who have been deniedā€

this is big, no?

Yeah the appeals page is same for everyone, so this is not an accurate indicator of any decision/result

oh nevermind then lol

It was brought up earlier as well lol

where? I have not authorized and I don’t see it anywhere

It’s higher up in this thread I’ll try to find it here

but it’s the same for everyone

Forbidden and not authorized can both see this page - does it cast some kind of doubt on this astrology then?

Think it’s just blocked for everyone and isn’t an indicator at all.

i still don’t trust this method yet. we can only rely on early admits — who are proposing very different answers. i urge everyone to wait a day or two to check the source code on their withdraw page to know for sure.

1 Like

there’s early admits with ā€œnot authorizedā€? i’ve asked about 10-12 early admits and they all have ā€œforbiddenā€, i’m yet to have run into an early admit with ā€œnot authorizedā€

2 Likes

not too sure

the only early admit I know got " forbidden"

1 Like