<p>It’s important to avoid making assumptions about the admissions process after reading College Confidential. This is hardly a representative group of the UChicago applicant pool. This is based purely on anecdotal evidence and things I’ve heard in info sessions, but compared to peer institutions, the University of Chicago’s EA admission rate holds little to no advantage over the regular decision rate. The reason I’ve heard given for this anomaly is that students applying in the early action cycle are more invested–they know they like the University of Chicago, and because of this, have better essays, Why Chicago statements, etc. And more specifically on your observation, considering the University of Chicago’s holistic admissions process, it’s not too surprising that 1600’s get rejected; it happens during EA as well as RD, I assure you. </p>
<p>As for your original question. A lot of people are afraid the self-selection that’s kept the school going for so many years died with the uncommon app, but I don’t believe it. They still call us “where fun goes to die”. I’m not worried. </p>
<p>And ditto JHS on the “for the hell of it” application point.</p>