I have never visited FSU, and we love UF - but in your situation I think @Gator88NE’s advice is spot on.
At times over the last 2 years I have seen OOS parents from UF lament the cost of English Comp 101, and such. Well, yes - it’s OOS tuition for a reason. That means that basic classes, if you don’t come in with credits, are going to be expensive.
Now if it was the business school, UF is definitely the right choice imho.
But for pre-meds, I’d be looking to save money and get the highest GPA possible.
I’m not sure that either school is particularly easy to fly into from NY. UCF would win that prize!