<p>
[Sigh.] No, it doesn’t, taking into account ALL NRC Rankings–1990s, 2010 S-rankings, and 2010 R-rankings. But I think we’ve laid out more than enough data at this point for other readers of this thread to draw their own conclusions (if they’re even still reading 
). And this is all kind of silly anyway given that we’re talking about rankings of Ph.D. programs, and lumping them together as “humanities” is something that has no relevance in the US graduate school world.</p>
<p>But let’s leave it that you and I (and RML, Alexandre and others in this thread) ALL agree that at the undergraduate level, these two phenomenal schools are comparable peers, and choosing one over the other for an undergraduate liberal arts education should simply be a matter of personal preference and fit. :)</p>