<p>OP, both schools are great and have great reputations. The difference, in spite of what others are arguing over is very small and varies in any given year. You will get a fine education at either place, but if you have fallen out of Chicago, and are picking up on a vibe that you don’t like, I think you have your answer. To worry about rankings and prestige differences in these two schools vs. where you feel you would fit better does not make sense. I think you know that, but are seeking approval for your decision. You don’t need it from us or anyone. Go to the school where you feel you will fit in best and you will end up better off there. </p>