@QuantMech I’m aware that MSU and CMU aren’t similarly ranked. However, I don’t put nearly as much stock in prestige as many on this forum do. I was told repeatedly when I was deciding between the two that I was an idiot for turning down U of M.
I think where you’re comfortable IS important to a college decision. If you feel more comfortable at CMU, you’re more likely to seek out opportunities, build networks, etc.
You’ll also notice that I DID recommend picking UMich.