Emory has a slight edge in academic, and perhaps overall, rep. I believe they are academic peers with schools like Vanderbilt, Notre Dame, WUSTL, CMU, Rice and Georgetown,
Tufts is the most selective currently (based on test scores and admit rate). It has a sort of LAC feel.
The Brandeis student body is known for community service involvement.
The U of Rochester is very good academically as well – probably underrated.
I think these schools are probably close enough in quality that you can feel confident that if you choose based on fit variables that are important to you, you will make the right decision.
Things to consider:
- Location, weather, campus feel, surrounding area/neighborhood
- Academic fit – programs offered, class sizes, ease of choosing and changing majors, academic calendar, curricular style (core vs. open)
- Cost (include travel)
- Social vibe – Greek and activism prevalence, party and sports scene, clubs, etc.