@Magnificence St. Bonnies has an overall Niche rating of B+, basically the top 25% of all schools ranked on Niche. Canisius is much lower ranked in basically the top 50%. The ratings are purely driven by students and alumni, so your comment about being crucified is not accurate.
Rate My Professor also has a section for school ratings as well.
Colleges know other colleges well, so your concerns are unfounded.
Bonaventure is a much nicer school than Canisius.