<p>The stats that you have listed for Vanderbilt don’t take into consideration the differences between schools. Peabody, Engineering, and Blair have higher acceptance rates because the applicant pools are more self-selecting. Vandy’s stats for A&S are probably more comparable to Duke’s because the applicant pool is larger… the acceptance rate this year for A&S will probably be a low 20-something percent.</p>
<p>This is all completely subjective and isn’t a strong indication of the reality of the school, but I was personally turned off by Duke because it seemed really unfriendly and overly focused on sports and Greek life (both of which seemed to have a negative presence). I know Vanderbilt has strong Greek life but for some reason it seemed more positive and welcoming, and the school spirit was fun (not hostile or intimidating). Also, the admissions office was extremely unfriendly at Duke, my tour guide was a nightmare, and… the freshman campus?? Oh my god. I guess this isn’t really a fair comment because it’s (unfortunately) based on one bad personal experience I had, but Durham and “East Campus” were big enough turn-offs alone.</p>
<p>It’s obviously still an incredible school, though. I guess it depends on your fit. My cousin goes and he likes it, but I could never see him at Vanderbilt.</p>