@ShivomP My daughter submitted one supplemental on kindness and got terrific feedback from two counselors, so absolutely no regrets. They said it would actually set her apart at the school she wrote it for.
That said, she LOVED CMC and the consortium! What an outstanding opportunity! Next to impossible to get in there! Have you visited? The Robert’s Pavilion was the very best rec center we toured. The school has amazing connections for internships and excellent placement for grad school. Graduate Schools | Claremont McKenna College
Lastly, socially, CMC combines with Harvey Mudd and Scripps for athletic teams, so your community is much larger, while academically, you are in the small academic environment of CMC, with the flexibility to take classes at the other consortium schools. The campuses are contiguous to each other, in a grid, so it is logistically unique and far more doable compared to the Amherst and Philly consortiums. And who doesn’t like California weather! Downtown Claremont is lovely also!
I noticed that you have some well-known and recognizable names on your wish list. Being from the east coast, I have noticed that many non-academic people from this area, especially New England don’t know much about the Claremont Consortium, nor much about the Midwestern LACs. Try to look at the environment of each school and ignore the „brand.“ You will have a wonderful future ahead of you in a school that REALLY wants YOU! Congratulations!