Did you hear this from an admissions officer, or did a coach tell you? Not that it matters really, just curious. Were all 25 deferred?
IF it’s true that 25 out of 70 or so recruited athletes (70 being a best guesstimate) who were fully supported with a slot and had positive pre-reads were not accepted at Wesleyan this year during the ED round, that would be FAR outside the norms of what is happening at other selective D3 schools, including the most selective NESCACs.