I think you have a good chance. Plenty of kids are nervous in interviews and not chatty. As long as you didn’t give one word answers and were able to look people in the eye and shake hands without being a wet noodle that part is probably fine.
International students have a harder time - I am assuming you are international?
Are those the only schools you are applying to? Lawrence Academy sticks out like a sore thumb - is it your “safety school” or do you love it?