<p>
</p>
<p>Oh really? Are you sure about that? </p>
<p>I’ll give you an example. A number of Nokia’s most successful handsets were largely designed by American-based researchers working in Nokia research labs. Nokia turns around and sells these handsets to customers around the world, especially in Europe, and yes often times even in Finland itself. So this could be construed to be that American researchers were “stealing” the jobs of Finns. The same could be said of the many thousands of Americans that Siemens hires. Many of them are scientists and researchers who are being hired to invent and develop new products that Siemens will sell around the world, including back in Germany. So maybe this is a case of Americans scientists and engineers “stealing” research jobs that should be going to Germans? </p>
<p>I’ll give you a related example. When the 2 French pharmaceutical giants Sanofi and Aventis merged to form Sanofi-Aventis (now the worlds 3rd largest pharmaceutical company after Pfizer and GlaxoSmithKline, and larger than Merck, Eli Lilly and Bristol Myers Squibb), the deal was completed by a consortium of 7 investment banks, including a number of American ones such as Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and Citigroup. Why were American investment banks involved in a merger of 2 French companies? Does this mean that American investment bankers were “stealing” jobs that should have gone to French bankers? I could just ask the question of why are American bankers making money off a French merger? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Is that supposed to be a joke? I think you’re the one who must be kidding. You constantly talk about how Indian software engineers can do things cheaper “over the wire”. Well that just begs the question, what is this ‘wire’? Answer, it’s data networking technology with which you build either a public network (like the Internet) or a private corporate network. And almost ALL of the data networking technology in the world is built by companies in developed nations, mostly American ones like Cisco Systems, Juniper, 3Com, and the like. India does not have a major data networking vendor. In fact, iaccording to Businessweek, n 2005, Cisco held 74% market share in India.</p>
<p><a href=“Businessweek - Bloomberg”>Businessweek - Bloomberg;
<p>So that means that you can visit any of these Indian offshoring companies and go to the backroom data wiring closet, and 3 times out of 4, you are going to find a whole stack of Cisco routers and switches. And if it’s not Cisco, then it will probably be Juniper gear or 3Com gear or gear from some other American networking vendor. </p>
<p>So maybe you should go blame Cisco, Juniper, and 3Com for building the network gear that allows India to build ‘the wire’ over which it can sell services. So maybe all of these American workers at Cisco should all be fired? Judging from the fact that Cisco is one of the most successful companies in the US and has been voted one of the best places to work by its employees for many years straight, I don’t think that Cisco employees are doing too badly. Cisco has the 2nd largest market cap of any company in Silicon Valley after Intel. One of the ‘crazes’ within India is to become Cisco-certified, meaning that you know how to properly set up a network of Cisco routers and switches. Why learn this skill if nobody in India uses Cisco equipment. </p>
<p>Or consider PC’s. You complain about Indian engineers doing cheap software work. Well, what are they doing that software work with? Are they using abacuses? No, they are using PC’s. And PC’s require microprocessors. India does not have a single x86 microprocessor manufacturer of note. Almost all of the x86 PC-compatible microprocessors in the world are manufactured by US companies, either Intel or AMD (with the Taiwanese company Via producing only a tiny fraction of the world’s production). Intel and AMD dominate the processor market in India. So maybe you should hound Intel and AMD for selling the processors that go into the computers that Indian workers use to ‘steal’ jobs from Americans.</p>
<p>Or consider the market for software. While I’m sure that a lot of software in India is pirated (as is a lot of software in the US), the respectable Indian companies, especially the major outsourcing companies, will adhere to respectable business practices. So if they use Windows, as most do, then they will pay for licensed copies, and so that revenue accrues to Microsoft. Or they can choose to use open-source Linux operating systems. Most Linux distributions are created by American Linux companies. The point is, India does not yet have a single major operating system vendor. Most of the operating systems are imported. </p>
<p>The point is that the technology industry in India (as it is for every country) is dominated by American high-tech vendors. If you want to ‘blame’ India for taking jobs away through tech outsourcing, then maybe you should first ‘blame’ the American high-tech companies who produce and sell the technology that India in order to do its outsourcing. Maybe American high-tech companies should give back all of the profits they made by selling to India, and for all those extra Americans that these high-tech companies hired to expand its business to sell in India, maybe they should all be fired. Right? </p>
<p>Or consider the consumer culture. McDonalds, Pizza Hut, KFC, Taco Bell, and many other American fast food restaurants have strong presences in India. So do Coca Cola and Pepsi. And so does American pop culture. American movies and TV shows are highly popular in India. The movie “Titanic” was HUGE in India (as it was everywhere in the world). So were the last 3 Star Wars movies. So maybe all of these American companies should immediately pull out of India and give back all of the profits they made in India. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I’m saying that if companies like Cisco and Coca Cola and McDonalds and Paramount Pictures (thorugh the movie Titanic) can make a lot of money from selling to India, then I don’t see why American companies should not be allowed to hire Indians. You seem to believe that American companies should be allowed to sell to foreigners, but never to hire them. In other words, this is economic colonialism, which is something that some Americans seem to want. </p>
<p>If American companies are not allowed to hire Indians, then American companies should not be allowed to sell anything to Indians. What’s fair is fair. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>That’s the choice of American consumers. Americans have the right to buy anything they want. If they choose to buy foreign products, then don’t blame the foreigners. You should go and blame the American consumer.</p>
<p>It reminds me of the ironic joke where an American tells a Japanese guy that the Japanese should buy more American cars. The Japanese guy turns around and looks at the Americans and says, no, the Americans should buy more American cars. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>And why is it a problem? Who says that trade deficits are “problems”? The measure of an economy is judged by how well off the CONSUMERS are, not how well off the producers are. As a consumer, I want lots of high quality goods for the least possible price. </p>
<p>Economists generally agree that trade deficits are not ‘problems’ in and of themselves. I doubt that you can do a better job of explaining it then Nobel Prize winner Milton Friedman. </p>
<p><a href=“http://www.ou.edu/class/econ3003/book/area1c35.html[/url]”>http://www.ou.edu/class/econ3003/book/area1c35.html</a></p>
<p>
</p>
<p>You just leave. Nobody is forcing you to stay. So you come here to discuss this thread, and then complain about being on this thread? What’s up with that?</p>