<p>
</p>
<p>Yeah, you may feel sorry for yourself. But hey, there are plenty of Americans who have had to work as janitors for THEIR WHOLE LIVES. How much sympathy do you think they are going to feel for somebody who worked as a computer professional for 3 decades and now finds that he has to now work as a janitor. At least he was making quite good money during those 3 decades. Plenty of people in the country can’t even say that.</p>
<p>Hence, I have 2 points to make. #1, right now, there are millions of Americans who don’t have good jobs (at least, the way we define ‘good’), and never did have them. Plenty of Americans can never seriously dream of buying their own house or sending their children to college. Plenty of Americans have always worked as low-wage earners simply trying to make ends meet. It’s not like all of them are laid-off computer professionals. Most of them had been low-wage earners their entire life. Hence, who really deserves sympathy, the guy who has had a high-wage job for many years and now finds himself doing low-wage work, or the guy who has always had to do low-age work? </p>
<p>Now let me raise my second point which is that for all the poverty in the country, notice how hardly of the poor chooses to leave. For example, it is poor Mexicans who sneak into the US to look for work, but poor Americans never sneak into Mexico looking for work. It is poor Chinese who will pay thousands of dollars to gangsters to be shipped in leaky boats to the US to end up working slave-type jobs in Chinatown, but you never see poor Americans trying to sneak into China to find work. The point is that the US is still a far far better place to be than many other places. A poor American still lives a far more prosperous lifestyle than billions of people around the world do. Let’s keep in mind that many people in the world don’t even have access to clean water or stable food supplies. We may pity those Americans who are stocking shelves or flipping burgers as having bad jobs, but believe me, there are plenty of people in the world who would give their right arm to take these ‘bad jobs’. So again, who really deserves our sympathy, the laid off computer engineer, or famine-stricken people in the Third World? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Why not? Again, look back in American history. One of the most important events in US economic history was the dawn of the US Industrial Revolution of the late 1800’s/early 1900’s. To make a long story short, tens of millions of American farmers lost their jobs due to mechanization of agriculture. A farmer with the proper equipment and tools could now do the work of several-hundred unequipped farmers. The result was that millions of farmers lost their jobs, a process that continues to this day. So what happened? Did all of these ex-farmers just all starve to death? No, of course not. Instead, most of them took jobs in the burgeoning industrial/manufacturing sector. </p>
<p>Also, let’s keep in mind that it wasn’t just a lucky coincidence that industry rose to absorb these millions of new hands. No, it was PRECISELY because there were all of these laborers available to create industry. After all, where else were all these new US factories going to find the millions of workers they needed, if not from the farms? Were all these workers just going to appear out of thin air? It is precisely because farming employment decreased that allowed industrial employment to increase. Farming had to decline for industry to rise. </p>
<p>By the same token, the only way that new US industries are going to rise today is for established industries to decline. That’s the way economics works. Trains used to be one of the most important industries in the nation. But it had to decline in order for the automobile industry to rise. Typewriters had to decline in order for the computer industry to rise. </p>
<p>The point is, all the concerns about how these computer guys are now being laid off with noplace to guy is not different from the lamentations of the past - i.e. what are all these laid-off farmers going to do, what are all these laid off train workers going to do, etc. The answer is, as long as the US economy is dynamic, new industries will rise and new jobs will be created. By its nature, nobody knows what these new jobs will be. For example, when the train industry declined, nobody knew that automobiles would take up the slack. Nobody can predict the future with certainty. But it has always been the case that new industries come along to absorb excess labor. </p>
<p>I agree, it’s a gutwrenching process, but that’s how economic growth works. Economic growth, by its nature, means doing something different, which often times means that people who have jobs today will lose them. After all, how can you grow the country if everybody is just doing exactly the same thing that they’ve always been doing? Economic growth by definition means that certain people have to do different things. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>But you’ve missed a basic tenet of economics, which is that when something gets cheaper, you tend to get more of it. Think of it this way. Why are countries shipping their jobs to India? Answer - by and large, because Indians are cheaper. And what happens when Indians are cheaper? Answer - you hire more of them.</p>
<p>So I agree, the workplace is a pyramid. But your fallacy is that those 8 laid-off American workers get turned into 8 jobs in India. In reality, they probably get turned into 50-75 jobs in India. After all, that’s part of the whole point of outsourcing - instead of hiring 1 American to be a coder, you can hire 5-10 Indians. Those 5-10 Indians then need a project manager - which is where the American can be effective.</p>
<p>Look, the point is that right now, Americans are unusually strong at management and related tasks. For example, while American ‘exports away’ a lot of low-end jobs, America also ‘imports’ a lot of high-end jobs. Keep in mind that oursourcing is a two way street. The US gets plenty of jobs from foreign companies choosing to locate offices in the US. For example, many Japanese firms like Sony, Hitachi, Fujitsu, etc. have extensive research and sales offices in Silicon Valley. You could say that that’s a case of the US actually importing jobs from Japan (and very high-wage jobs). Those firms could have chosen to only have offices in Japan and hire only Japanese. But they didn’t do that - they chose to hire Americans. Many foreign companies choose to hire American advertising firms to run not only their advertising within the US, but also around the world. Hence, the US is actually ‘importing’ advertising jobs from around the world. And of course, many foreign companies choose to obtain financing and capital from US-based banks, usually NYC based investment banks. In fact, many countries don’t even have their own well-developed financial industry, choosing instead to tap US resources. So that’s a case of the US ‘importing’ finance jobs from other countries.</p>