What the Fastest Growing Jobs Pay

<p>

</p>

<p>I would see absolutely no reason to transition out of the IT market and I don’t think this behavior is “healthy”. These aren’t crap jobs that are being replaced by lower, third world countries. They are wonderful, well above average, upper middle class jobs that are being lost and this is NOT healthy for the economy.</p>

<p>I can see how farming fits into this. Americans used to farm but now in general, they’ve moved on to bigger and better jobs while other third world countries have taken up farming. So yeah, the transition was healthy for the country.</p>

<p>But can this analogy be really used to describe the IT industry? First of all, the IT industry payed handsomely to Americans. Second The average IT programmer/consultant/other worker with a college degree STARTING made 50K+ while the average long term IT/engineer made 80K+. The average salary in America is less than 30K! </p>

<p>This isn’t like going from farming to other, more sophisticated jobs. If anything, it’s the other way around. Employment is everything. It is the key and a backbone to a country’s economy. In general, if you find more people better paying jobs; the country will thrive better. Outsourcing is taking away jobs that were paying a lot of money and it is not healthy.</p>

<p>There is a new book out called “Outsourcing America”. Basically no one really cares whether new better jobs are created or not. No one really expects new better jobs to be created. American workers no longer even deserve rationalizations or theories. Outsourcing is being done by corporations who only care about their bottom line. Of course there will be no one to buy their products but that is why you need an external force like the government to step in. If each corporation acts in their own self interest it ultimately is not in anyone’s self-interest. But if one corporation decides not to outsource on their own, their costs will just be higher and they still won’t have anyone to buy their products.</p>

<p>The analogy to farms would be when the government after the depression started price supports and supply controls. Every farmer acting alone would plant as much as he could which would result in price collapse. Sometimes governments have to step in.</p>

<p>And lower prices don’t justify outsourcing. So people who still have jobs will pay less for things. It’s more of the same winner takes all. I would rather pay a little more for everything and have some job security and a future for my children.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Well, let me state a few things.</p>

<h1>1 - First off, nowhere is it written that Americans are automatically entitled to all of the IT jobs in the world. And in fact, in general, just because you’re an American doesn’t mean that you’re automatically entitled to have a good job. Nowhere is it written that the Indian IT worker who “takes” (if that is the right word) a job from an American worker is any less deserving of that job. Indians are people too, and they have the same aspirations and hopes for a good life that everybody does.</h1>

<h1>2 - IT is arguably the most “destructive” industry in world history in the sense that the reason that the whole reason for the existence of the IT industry is to increase productivity. And what does increased productivity mean? It generally means destruction of jobs, at least in the short term. Take the Internet. How many traditional companies have either laid people off, or simply hired fewer people in the first place, because of the Internet? For example how many travel agents have been rendered unemployed and unemployable because of Expedia and Travelocity? How many flea markets and specialty collector stores have gone bankrupt because of Ebay? How many small-time book sellers, especially used book sellers, have gone out of business because of Amazon? How many encyclopedia salesmen are out of a job because of the rise of MS Encarta and wikipedia?</h1>

<p>You can even take a look at the bowels of corporate IT and note how much ‘job destruction’ IT has caused. For example, when the first IBM PC’s came out and became popular among businesspeople, it resulted in huge layoffs of secretaries, as managers discovered that they could now easily type up their own documents. I remember when my old employer installed some financial accounting software - and then proceed to lay off most of the accounting staff as the software could now do the same job as all of those accountants. The same thing happened when the company installed a supply-chain and inventory warehouse manager, and then proceeded to lay off much of the warehouse and distribution management staff. In fact, almost all corporate IT features exist to take the place of jobs that were formerly handled by people. </p>

<p>I don’t see what is the difference between having your job replaced by some guy in a foreign country and having your job replaced by a computer. Either way, the job is gone. Yet it seems as if outsourcing somehow garners some special invective. I guess it’s a lot easier to vent your anger at another person in some other country rather than to vent it against a computer. </p>

<h1>3 - One could say that the decline of highly-paid, yet relatively low-skilled manufacturing jobs, is the direct parallel to the loss of highly-paid IT jobs. Yet America has not, on the whole, really suffered from the loss of those manufacturing jobs. Certain unions have suffered. Certain regions of the country have suffered, like Detroit. But on the whole, the loss of manufacturing jobs has probably been a boon.</h1>

<p>Note - loss of manufacturing jobs does not mean a loss of manufacturing output. The US produces more manufactured goods than it ever has in its history, and with only a fraction of the manufacturing workforce. How? Simple - highly levels of productivity and capital investment. Just like US farms produce more food than ever while employing fewer people than ever, because technology advances continue to improve the productivity of each individual farmer. Similarly, each unit of manufacturing output requires far fewer total manufacturing workers to produce it. </p>

<p>Why has this change been good? Because it has emphasized the importance of education in the country. Back in the old days, the lure of high-paid manufaturing jobs served as a huge impediment to educational attainment. Kids would ask why they should bother studying hard in school and going to college when they could instead just start working on a manufacturing line starting when they’re 18 and do that for the rest of their lives. The decline of manufacturing has paralleled a rise in educational achievement, and the availability of highly educated workers has allowed the US to develop new knowledge-based industries. This has been an especially important achievement for the economic liberation of women, because many women are simply not capable of doing the physical work necessary for many manufacturing jobs - but they can do the knowledge-based work required in a knowledge-based industry. Women will never be as physically strong as men (on average), but women can certain match wits with anybody.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Yeah, but what is the unemployment rate? Something around 4.5%, one of the lowest rates in the country’s history. Keep in mind that during the Great Depression, the unemployment rate reached well over 25%. </p>

<p>It’s also not about just finding people better paying jobs. It’s really about finding people jobs that will allow them to sustain their lifestyle. So one key factor is how much it costs to sustain that lifestyle. For example, if I cut everybody’s wages in half, but I also cut everybody’s prices in half, then everybody is exactly the same as before. No better off, but no worse off. </p>

<p>The real key is to maintain high levels of economic flexibility to allow for new industries to develop. For example, maybe the answer is in real estate. Hundreds of thousands of people became real-estate brokers and mortgage lenders in the last few years because of the housing boom, and many of them made far more money than they would have doing anything else. I know a number of former IT people who became real estate agents, and they say they make more money now than they ever did in IT. Maybe the key is in trade and shipping management. For example, as manufacturing declined in the Netherlands, Dutch workers moved to become experts in international shipping, taking advantage of the excellent ports and harbors availabile in the Netherlands. As the US continues to source more parts from Asia, we will need people who are experts in managing those long supply chain networks and logistics. In fact, I know one guy who just graduated from MIT has taken a job at Apple where he will be in charge of managing the procurement of Ipod components from China. Apple has an entire coterie of people who are doing just that - managing its far-flung manufacturing operations around the world. Maybe health care is the key, as the Baby Boom gets older and requires more care. For example, I have noticed the burgeoning demand for more nurses and physician’s assistants. These jobs pay fairly well. </p>

<p>Let’s not also forget that outsourcing has actually CREATED many extremely high paying American jobs. For example, Sony runs several large R&D divisions in the US, including a big one in Silicon Valley. So do Hitachi, Fujitsu, NEC, and a host of other Japanese companies. These are high-paying research jobs created in the US. Nokia, which is a Finnish company, runs extensive R&D operations in the US. So does Samsung, a Korean company. I know near MIT, the Swiss pharmaceutical giant Novartis just completed several gleaming new research buildings. All of these companies are basically “outsourcing” extremely high paying jobs to Americans. How can the US really say that it is OK for foreign companies to outsource jobs to the US, but it is not OK when American companies outsource jobs to foreigners? </p>

<p>Or consider the entire financial services and investment banking industry that is centered around New York City. Wall Street bankers make financial deals not just for American companies. They finance companies all around the world. But think about that. That basically means that the world is basically “outsourcing” extremely-highly paid finance jobs to the US. If every country in the world elected to build its own financial industry, that would mean far less work for American bankers. The same can be said for management consulting, an industry that is utterly dominated by Americans. American consultants fly around the world consulting for companies around the world. What that basically means is that the world is basically “outsourcing” its consulting jobs to Americans. </p>

<p>The point is that while outsourcing may taketh away, it also giveth. Some Americans may lose their jobs to outsourcing, but other Americans have jobs precisely because of outsourcing. If you want to say that American companies should not be allowed to outsource jobs to foreigners, then you have to also believe that foreign companies should not be allowed to outsource jobs to Americans. So all of the Americans who are employed by foreign companies should all be fired right now because they are ‘stealing’ the jobs that should be going to foreigners.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>No-one to buy the products? Why do you say that? US household wealth is at record highs, and in fact, has been setting new records for at least the last 10 quarters.</p>

<p><a href=“Home | London Free Press Home Page | London Free Press”>Home | London Free Press Home Page | London Free Press;

<p>No doubt much of this rise has been due to the precipitous appreciation in housing prices in the last few years, but that still means that Americans are now richer in terms of net wealth than they have ever been before. I’ve been talking to a number of Americans who have remarked at just how much money they made in selling their houses. </p>

<p>Or let’s take a look at some of the salaries available to new college graduates. Yes, some salaries have declined, possible due to outsourcing. But more salaries have gone up. The net effect is that more Americans are gaining than losing. Economics/finance and accounting people really cleaned up, and chemical engineers and civil engineers didn’t do too shabbily either. I am also quite impressed by the increased salaries available to liberal arts majors. </p>

<p><a href=“http://money.cnn.com/2006/02/13/pf/college/starting_salaries/index.htm[/url]”>http://money.cnn.com/2006/02/13/pf/college/starting_salaries/index.htm&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>I agree that a dynamic economy that includes outsourcing may hurt some people. But it also helps others. For example, a company that can save money on outsourcing can and often does choose to spend that money on other new business initiatives. I suspect that’s why the salaries for econ/finance and for general liberal arts majors has increased. The economy is investing more in natural resources, especially oil, which is surely why chemical engineering salaries continue to rise. The economy is also constructing new buildings, and new transportation infrastructure, hence the improvement in civil engineering salaries. Overall, I see no cause for alarm. </p>

<p>After all, think of it this way. You say that corporations are out to look after only their bottom line. I agree. But then why is it that companies are willing to pay more for chemical engineers? And Econ/finance people? Why don’t all these companies just pay them minimum wage? Instead, they are actually INCREASING the salaries offered to them. Why is that? Surely these companies aren’t just stupidly throwing money away? </p>

<p>So maybe that’s the answer right there. You want a relatively high-paying job? Get a degree in chemical engineering. 56k is not a bad starting salary. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Yet by creating price supports and supply controls, you just create a system of redistribution where not only do tax dollars go to support farmers, but even worse, everybody has to pay higher prices for food.</p>

<p>A better way to go about it is to simply give farmers some money to transition them out of farming, but not to use price supports. Price supports only screws over those poor people who are now farmers who now have to pay extra for food. What about those people? </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Yeah, but what about those foreigners who are getting those outsourced jobs? They have children too, you know. While those jobs may pay a pittance compared to what Americans make, it’s still better than whatever else is available in those countries. </p>

<p>I personally, do not see what is so different between outsourcing somebody’s job to another (cheaper) part of the country and just outsourcing it to another country entirely. For example, historically, most of the US textile industry was located in the Northeast, but now what remains of it is mostly located in the American South. US car manufacturing is moving away from high-cost areas like Michigan and to lower-cost states like Georgia, Kentucky, and Tennessee. So the job is taken either by a lower-paid American located somewhere else in the country, or by a lower-paid foreigner. Either way, the job is gone. And why is it that the autoworker in Michigan deserves the job, but the autoworker in Kentucky or Tennessee doesn’t deserve the job? </p>

<p>Furthermore, I also don’t see the difference between simply outsourcing a job to India, and just eliminating the job completely through technology. For example, let’s use the example of IT. IT workers can often times be replaced by better enterprise management software which allows me to run enterprise computer systems infrastructure with less people. So what’s the difference between a company that outsources its IT work to India, and laying off existing American IT staff and a company that installs this management software which also allows it to lay off its existing staff? Either way, the staff is laid off.</p>

<p>Read Grapes of Wrath. You don’t know anything about the history of farm supports. Did you take any econ courses? Every farmer seeks to maximize his own profits and therefore produces as much as he can. Because he can’t control prices this is the only way to make more money. If everyone produces as much as he can, the market is glutted and all the farmers go out of business. In Grapes of Wrath the fruit was rotting in the fields because it wasn’t worth picking. Everyone has to outsource because everyone else is outsourcing.</p>

<p>And I for one care more about my job than about a job in India. I’m just funny that way. Other countries do not care as much about you as they do about their own nationals. China and India have national programs to try to lure your job to their countries while our country sells us out.</p>

<p>“and they have the same aspirations and hopes for a good life that everybody does.”
I would support that…I mean people here are living in difficulties or problems that an average american cannot even imagine (not that i faced any) but I know of present state secretaries and leading indian doctors who studies under street lamps…
Now earlier when i used to discuss this with my friends in US they used to tell me that an average american need not worry because their economy is so strong…but then people i think now that the independence shock is over for india…people are working their @ss off and its time the US people worry and work the insane hours to keep their job…If u loose a job its nobody’s fault but your own…and Earlier i read someone post abt a 40 yr old guy not getting enough time to spend time with his family if he works like the 20 something people…well then his problem…i personally know such individual who had to work 18hrs a day for quite a bit of his life to provide good schooling,clothing, and living for his children…him being my father…
Basically, all i want to say is that this is a crazily competitive world…and u need to work hard.
In every field the competition is fierce…i mean say 10 or 15 years back in india people getting marks in the range of 60’s or 70’s was awwesome but now its become 90’s and even 95…What to do…should everyone start complaining that other kids are performing better and therefore we are facing a loss in the form of seats in colleges which we always had…cant do that can we…same’s the case here</p>

<p>I feel sorry for all of the people of the 3rd world but that is not what is motivating outsourcing. The government and heads of corporations in the U.S. are selling out their own people. Europeans are not being asked to give up their 1st world lifestyle to compete with everyone else in the world. The people in the U.S. get suckered into voting for people based on issues like abortion, gay marriage, etc. and let people give away their jobs wholesale. Outsourcing is not good for the vast majority of Americans. It doesn’t even lower prices very much. It raises profits but if you have an $80,000 job and lose it you will not be a stockholder for very long. The government also helps Americans lose jobs through technical visas. I worked with people who came in on those visas and they were very run-of-the-mill programmers who were doing jobs that many Americans could do and were being paid less money with no benefits. The companies have to claim that they can’t find Americans to do the jobs which is a bold-faced lie.</p>

<p>"The government and heads of corporations in the U.S. are selling out their own people. Europeans are not being asked to give up their 1st world lifestyle to compete with everyone else in the world. "
This i agree wih completely…I think the US govt. is trying to act like sort of gods for all in distress and in turn sacrificing some of the Americans benefits…for one when US people were secured about their living standards we were seeing many prodigies coming out of America in every field…business,corporations,music,arts,research…because with the open ended policy the people worked only on what they wanted to work on caring little about future prospects but now they have to mold their careers according to the market…</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Surely you don’t want me to answer that question, do you? Trust me, I have a good grasp on economics. You may want to search through some of my old posts if you think that my economics knowledge is lacking. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Since you wanted me to prove my economics knowledge, let’s do so. The Austrian economist Joseph Schumpeter coined the phrase ‘creative destruction’ in which healthy economies have to constantly reallocate resources away from declining industries and towards wherever the returns are greatest. That often times involves pain for those declining industries, but that is the way that the economy adapts. </p>

<p>You talk about prices in the context of the Depression. However, prices have a key use in economics, in that they serve primarily as market signals to ration supply and demand. When prices are low, that sends a signal to suppliers that the market does not want as many items as you are producing and that you need to start producing less, and in the context of industrial economics, it means that some of the producers need to stop producing and exit the industry to do something else where the resources can be more properly allocated. In other words, markets are micro-regulated through the price mechanism. This is the “Invisible Hand” that Adam Smith postulated, and for which Freidrich Hayek explained (and which later won him the Nobel Prize in Economics) as a case of ‘spontaneous order’ - the actions of myriad economic players can all be coordinated through the price mechanism, despite the fact that none of the players knows what the other players are doing. This spontaneous order is a far far more efficient method of allocating resources than centralized mechanisms - witness the huge economic failures of the Soviet Union, which was a huge net exporter before the days of collectivism and then was later forced to embarrassingly import massive quantitites of grain despite having some of the best farmland in the world. Not only that, but the small plots that the Soviet Union allowed its citizens to farm privately were far more productive in terms of yield per acre than any of the collective farms. Simply put, the Soviet Union refused to allow the price mechanisms to yield to market forces, and in particular, did not compensate Soviet farmers for producing more on collective farms, which massively blunted the incentives to work hard and produce more. </p>

<p>So let’s take it back to the case of US farm subsidies. You are correct to say that low prices caused great hardship amongst the farming community. But they caused great hardship everywhere. Basically, low agricultural prices were supposed to signal that the country needed fewer farmers, which should have spurred more farmers to do something else, and in the very least not to expend more resources (in terms of labor and capital) on agriculture when the nation simply didn’t need it. I agree that that’s painful for the farmers, which is why what should have been done is for the government to step in and not to encourage people to farm more through subsidies, but to help them to transition to some other job. </p>

<p>Through a system of price supports, what you have done is, first of all, eliminated the price signal as a useful market mechanism. That basically encourages farmers to stay in farming and continue to produce when they should have stopped, hence causing a glut of produce. The Soviet Union experienced the same problem in not properly coordinating their centralized prices, such that when it set prices too high, too many goods were produced, which would then have to be discarded. </p>

<p>Secondly, price supports served to redistribute resources away from everybody else, including other poor people. To this day, we as Americans have to pay about double what people in other countries pay for sugar, and substantially more than the world market price for bread, milk, and other foodstuffs. Amazon, you talk about poor farmers who are in pain. Well, what about poor people who are not farmers? They just got completely screwed because price supports forces them to pay more for food than they would have to otherwise. Since they’re poor too, it’s not like they have a whole lot of money, so where’s the justice in making it more expensive for them to buy food? Why should poor farmers benefit at the expense of poor non-farmers?</p>

<p>Finally, the most pernicious part of farm subsidies and price supports is that it creates what economists call “rent-seeking behavior”, something that was alluded to be David Ricardo. Basically, farm subsidies and price supports encourage the cheek-to-jowl relationship between the government and the farming industry such that farming industry lobbies and finances many a political campaign so as to continue to get paid what are called economic rents in the forms of ever more farm subidies. </p>

<p>Look at it this way, amazon. I agree that farmers needed help back in the dark days of the Depression. But why should they continue to receive extensive financial support even during the boom years? I also thought that farm subsidies were supposed to target poor individual farmers. Yet the vast majority of farm subsidies these days goes to large farms and especially to Big Business agricultural corporations like ConAgra, Cargill, and Archer Daniels Midland. Why exactly do these big corporations need to get paid millions from the government? Yet that’s what inevitably happens whenever you create a political program that helps a certain political constituency - that constituency inevitably starts to treat it as an entitlement and will exert political pressure to obtain that subsidy forever. Very few government programs ever get ended for precisely this reason - because those who benefit from the program will try to manipulate the political process to keep that program alive even when the program has far outlived its usefulness.</p>

<p>And personally, I think the most morally objectionable aspect of farm subsidies is that it devastates farmers in other countries, especially those in the Third World. Many foreign farmers simply can’t compete against subsidized American agriculture, so they all lose their jobs, and those nations can’t generate any income. Why is the farmer from Kansas or France getting subsidized, when nobody is subsidizing the poor farmer from Africa? It is precisely these kinds of things that stir up anger towards Western nations. Western nations preach free trade and free markets when they want to do business in other countries, but they’re not willing to remove market-distorting policies in their own countries.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>There’s fear mongering and then there are the facts:

[url=<a href=“http://www.economist.com/displaystory.cfm?story_id=4135319]Ignorance”>Getting the measure of it]Ignorance</a> and the fear of offshoring<a href=“I%20love%20the%20Economist”>/url</a></p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Well, it’s good to see that at least you admit that you care more about Americans than about foreigners. Some people who oppose outsourcing claim to be doing it for the good of everyone, when secretly this is not so. At least you’re honest about your motivations. I give you credit for that. </p>

<p>However, I strongly disagree that the country has no programs to try to lure business from other countries. Very strongly disagree. In fact, much of American economic history has been all about how the US government has attempted to lure business from other countries. For example, keep in mind that the US did not start life as a rich and powerful country. In fact, in the early years, the US was quite impoverished and undeveloped, relative to the powerhouses in Europe. During the early years, the US developed largely by attracting massive amounts of capital from the extraordinarily rich banking houses and merchant guilds of Europe. European banks and companies, notably British, Dutch, and French, built a significant amount of the early infrastructure and industrial base of the US. British companies, in particular, built a number of large factories and looms in the US for one simple reason - it was cheaper to produce in the US than to build more factories back in the UK. Much of the US industrial boom of the late 1800’s was financed from London. European companies built extensive operations in the US because it was efficient to do so. Basically, Europe was effectively ‘outsourcing’ to the US, and that’s what made the US rich. How can the US really complain about lost jobs through outsourcing now when the fact is, the US gained numerous jobs through outsourcing in the past? In the early years of the US, it was the US that was the low-cost producer and that’s why the US gained many jobs. </p>

<p>Even to this day, the US runs extensive policies to encourage foreign companies to outsource jobs to the US. For example, the US enacts strong import quotas of cars to prevent foreign car companies from selling too many foreign cars. However, it is perfectly OK for a foreign car company to establish factories in the US, as these cars are not subject to import quotas. Not only that, but local state governments, especially in the Southern states, provide strong tax and regulatory incentives for foreign auto companies to establish operations in their states. The result - numerous huge foreign auto manufacturing facilities have been built in the US. For example, what was for many years the largest single automobile manufacturing plant in the world was the Nissan plant located in Smyrna, Tennessee. The plant has since been surpassed in capacity but remains one of the largest auto plants in the world. Nissan has another huge super-plant in Canton, Mississippi. Where is the largest Honda plant in the world? It’s not in Japan, it’s in Lincoln, Alabama. Toyota runs one of its largest plants in the world in Georgetown, Kentucky, and another in Princeton, Indiana. Hyundai has built a giant plant in Montgomery, Alabama. Mercedes-Benz has a large plant in Tuscaloosa, Alabama. BMW has a big plant in Spartanburg, South Carolina. </p>

<p>Almost all of these foreign plants are subsidized by the government, either the Fed, or the state government. So how can you really say that the US is not trying to lure jobs from overseas? Tell that to the autoworker in Tennessee who is working at the Nissan plant that the government has not tried to lure employment from overseas. </p>

<p>Here is some news that crows about how various Southern states have bagged extensive investment from various foreign auto manufacturers. </p>

<p><a href=“http://www.mississippi.org/content.aspx?url=/page/autoindustry&[/url]”>http://www.mississippi.org/content.aspx?url=/page/autoindustry&&lt;/a&gt;
<a href=“http://www.bizjournals.com/birmingham/stories/2004/01/26/focus3.html[/url]”>http://www.bizjournals.com/birmingham/stories/2004/01/26/focus3.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Furthermore, one might say that all of this foreign investment doesn’t make up for the problems of the US manufacturers, notably Ford and GM. I don’t know about that. </p>

<p>"… Look past the trouble in Detroit, and the auto industry is anywhere but in decline. In a growing number of Southern hamlets such as Canton, Toyota ™, Honda (HMC), Mercedes, and other foreign car manufacturers are providing nonunionized jobs – 33,000 since 2000 – that pay almost as much as United Auto Workers earn farther north. Consumers are enjoying more choice than ever, while the market as a whole is humming. Car sales in the U.S. inched up last year, to 17 million vehicles, the third-highest ever.</p>

<p>And get this: Even as Ford and GM cut production last year, North American plants built 15.8 million cars and trucks, the same as in 2004. That happened thanks to foreign carmakers producing 4.9 million vehicles, an increase of 500,000 from 2004. Overall production is expected to rise to 16.8 million by 2009, when an estimated 5.8 million vehicles will roll off foreign-owned assembly lines. Looking back, car and truck production in the U.S. has nearly doubled since Detroit’s heyday in the early 1960s.</p>

<p>“The domestic auto industry is as healthy as it has ever been,” says Eric Noble, president of Car Lab, an industry consulting firm in Santa Ana, Calif. “The names on the plants are just changing.”</p>

<p><a href=“Businessweek - Bloomberg”>Businessweek - Bloomberg;

<p>Let’s keep in mind that while the Southern plants may not pay quite as well as plants in Michigan do, they’re pretty close. Furthermore, the South is a cheaper place to live. So, really, from a cost-of-living perspective, the average US auto worker may actually be better off than ever. Let’s face it. Making $20 an hour is a lot of money in rural Mississippi, especially for somebody with no college degree. </p>

<p>Besides, look at it this way. Who says that the autoworker in Michigan is any more deserving of a job than an autoworker in Tennessee or South Carolina or Kentucky or Mississippi or Georgia? Last time I checked, there were all Americans. </p>

<p>I could go on and on, particularly about the large US government subsidies which have served to create a huge science and technology industry that most countries, especially Third World countries, lack. Again, why is it that so many foreign tech companies open R/D centers in the US? Why does Sony hire so many American researchers? Why not fire them all and replace them with Japanese? Why do Shell and BP hire so many American engineers? Why not fire them all and replace them with Brits? Nokia hires plenty of Americans in the Nokia Research Center. Why? Aren’t those Americans ‘stealing’ jobs from Finns? </p>

<p>The point is, plenty of foreign companies hire plenty of Americans, often times with US government help and subsidy. If you want to say that the Chinese and Indian governments should not be encouraging US companies to invest overseas, then fine, the US government and the state governments should not be encouraging foreign companies to invest in the US.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>But again, how is this any different from investments in labor-saving technology? The Internet started life as a government research project in the Department of Defense. Nowadays, as I explained earlier, the Internet is being used to effectively ‘destroy’ millions of jobs. Like I said, how many travel agents no longer have jobs because of the rise of Internet travel sites like Expedia and Travelocity? How many people who work in the mall like store cashiers and shelf-stockers no longer have jobs because people are buying more things through Amazon and other ecommerce sites? How many librarians lost their jobs (or were never hired in the first place) because of Google and wikipedia? Should all those people who lost their jobs because of the Internet blame the government for creating the technology that destroyed their jobs? </p>

<p>Or forget about the Internet. Let’s talk about technology in general. The US government has spent billions of dollars in encouraging the development of other high technology like robots, advanced software, electronics, materials science and so forth, and most of these developments have commercial applications. For example, most new US manufacturing facilities, especially in the auto industry, make extensive use of industrial robots. How many autoworkers have been replaced by robots? How many bank tellers have lost their jobs from ATM’s and online banking? How many auto mechanics have lost their jobs because cars are more reliable than they were in the past? How many airplane mechanics have lost their jobs because aerospace companies are using new materials and technologies to make airplanes more reliable? The advent of supply chain and inventory software has resulted in many warehouse and distribution managers losing their jobs, the advent of accounting and financial software has resulted in many bookkeepers and accountants losing their job. The rise of online music sites like ITunes may mean that eventually, many record stores may go out of business, throwing all of their employees out of work. </p>

<p>The point is, I don’t know why we are so fixated on outsourcing, when the fact is, simple technological advancement eliminates far far more jobs than outsourcing does. I guess it’s easy to become infuriated at a company for ‘giving’ your job to somebody else, but not so easy when your company ‘gives’ your job to a computer or a robot. But honestly, what’s the difference? Whether the company has a foreigner do your job, or just eliminates your job completely through technology, the job is still gone. So, really, what’s the difference? </p>

<p>What is really happening is that while technology may eliminate many jobs, it also creates many more. Basically, technology serves to free up labor so that that labor can do other things. While that might sound flip, the fact is, the US has one of the lowest unemployment rates in its history, and despite tremendous technological advances. The Internet, for example, might have destroyed some jobs, but it also created others, most notably at all of the Internet companies and jobs building and maintaining websites and network infrastructure. Robots might have destroyed some manufacturing jobs, but also created other jobs in maintaining and designing robots and allowed companies to save capital which they could use to hire more people to do product design and development rather than as simple laborers on the assembly line.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Oh really? Are you sure you want to go down this road? In fact, globalization and outsourcing have been HUGE trends in Europe. In fact, ever since the fall of the Berlin Wall and the admission into the EU of many of the nations in Central & Eastern Europe, one of the biggest trends of Western European companies is to relocate facilities to take advantage of lower labor costs. This has caused a huge boom in nations such as Slovakia, Poland, Hungary, Romania, and Bulgaria.</p>

<p>"What few anticipated is that the once-bankrupt economies of Central Europe would move up the industrial food chain so quickly and attract research jobs in knowledge-driven industries ranging from telecoms to autos to pharmaceuticals. Now, thanks to their growing ranks of high-skilled workers, these countries are shaping up as the next outsourcing haven for engineering and software development, just behind China and India.</p>

<p>Evidence of this next chapter in the global outsourcing saga is everywhere. In offices above an Audi dealership in Sofia, for instance, engineers working for Idaho-based AMI Semiconductor Inc. (AMIS ) are busy developing next-generation chips for automobiles and medical equipment. AMIS set up an office in the Bulgarian capital after its managers in Belgium noticed they were getting a lot of applications from qualified Bulgarian semiconductor specialists. Anelia Mladenova Pergoot, a native Bulgarian who worked 16 years for AMIS in Belgium, returned home to run the new office, which plans to double staff, to 40, by next year. “I’m impressed by the level of quality the technical universities have been able to support,” she says.</p>

<p>In the Czech Republic, investments in such sectors as software and customer-service centers rose 150% in 2004. According to IBM, Hungary, Poland, and the Czech Republic ranked among the top 10 global destinations for research and development jobs in the first half of 2005. In Europe, only Britain attracted more R&D work. Some 67% of the Polish economy is already made up of services, says the Organization of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). Case in point: Hewlett-Packard’s five-year-old information-technology outsourcing center in Warsaw, which employs 1,000, and its new $54 million business-process outsourcing center in Wroclaw, which opened in April and is expected to create another 1,000 jobs. HP already generates $550 million in revenues in Poland…"</p>

<p>"How did Central Europe gain this momentum? It started with the manufacturing plants coming in from the West. Even now, carmakers and their suppliers are plowing billions into Central Europe to build brand-new plants and add production lines at existing ones. Toyota (TM ) Motor, Volkswagen, General Motors (GM ), PSA Peugeot Citro</p>

<p>Listen people…now that we are done with unemployment…
I have been told that consulting (tech or anything) is the only field that offers money compared to Ibanking…so what are the usual pay scales like for tech consultants and can anyone explain to me what exactly is the work of these people.</p>

<p>I’d rather be an unemployed person in Europe than a Walmart employee - at least you have healthcare. Now we’re done with unemployment.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Oh really? Tell that to all of those youths who burned Paris a few months ago. A number of factors contributed to the civil unrest, but one key factor is the tremendous lack of economic opportunity in France for anybody who isn’t ethnically French.</p>

<p><a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_civil_unrest_in_France[/url]”>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_civil_unrest_in_France&lt;/a&gt;
<a href=“http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_situation_in_the_French_suburbs[/url]”>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_situation_in_the_French_suburbs&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>So apparently being unemployed in Europe ain’t a whole lot of fun. Otherwise, if it was so enjoyable, why were these people rioting?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Nothing, except maybe entrepreneurship, compares to the kind of money you can make in Ibanking. The best Ibankers can make more money in 1 year than the best tech consultants can make in their entire lifetimes. Tech consultants get paid well, but not THAT well. </p>

<p>Tech consultants are simply that - people who provide expertise about how to build and use technology. It can range from simple “code-monkey” work, i.e. actually writing code and putting together servers and routers together for a company, to high-level strategy consulting, i.e. advising a company about how to best utilize technology to obtain strategic advantage in the market.</p>

<p>It’s kind of interesting. Teaching isn’t mentioned anywhere but there is always a need for teachers, we won’t be outsourced, and as a veteran teacher I make more money than most of the listed jobs ($72,000). I’m also nowhere near top salary, by the way, which in my district is over $90,000. I wish more students considered teaching because it is intrinsically rewarding and the pay’s not bad.</p>

<p>Sakky - the rioting youth have all had an excellent public school education - all public schools in France are equal and good, and their mothers had access to excellent state funded daycare if that was what they wanted. They also have free healthcare. So right off the bat they have a better head start than most people who end up working at Walmart. Yes people of Arab descent in France are probably discriminated against but people here who go to crappy public schools with no labs, textbooks, etc. (Savage Inequalities) are not going to end up as investment bankers either.</p>

<p>Can we please stop this now?</p>

<p>ocliberal - my daughter’s first choice was to be a teacher but I know people who are having a hard time breaking into that field. My friend (a laid-off programmer who can’t find a job) got a Master’s in elementary ed and is now working at a private school for something in the 30’s and can’t break into a nice suburban school where she’d make the big bucks. Do you have to either teach math and science or in an inner-city school to get a job?</p>