When is an engineer not an engineer?

<p>But the question is whether or not law schools cut any significant amount of “slack” for having a more rigorous undergraduate major or for attending a school with grade deflation. I surely hope they take that into consideration, but my impression from reading others’ posts are that they don’t give it alot of importance. Do you have any personal or peripheral experience with law school admissions, sparks? Thanks in advance…</p>

<p>Alright the Dean of Law at U of I (also very involved in the admissions process) said he gives engineers more of a chance (because they know how to work hard and are used to it as opposed to a poly sci major) but he also said that he is very UNLIKE most other law schools in this respect. He knows what engineers have to go through and doesn’t care as much to let in others that won’t live up to expectation (and those stupid, important rankings) just because they have higher GPAs. But most others do.</p>

<p>There are other factors and those factors are individual to the college like for Stanford diversity is important and if you definitely want to go into patent law many law schools are looking to expand in this aread at specific schools. He said that right now the Law School is talking to the engineering school at U of I trying to get them to raise the curve but I can tell you right now that is NOT going to happen. So you’re at a disadvantage but hopefully you can find out if the law school you want, would like other things that you could excel in and put more of an effort in to doing or something. Just work extra hard at getting that GPA up as high as possible (take extra classes that are easier or over the summer at a community college or online and transfer the credits and grade). Plus a rise in GPA would show improvement, some else tha tis important for law school.</p>

<p>Good luck I’m heading in the same direction of getting my GPA up and hoping my honors designation and a couple of things hit me in the right direction.</p>

<p>The admissions “incentives” are stacked against low GPAs. Why would a law school cut some slack when its got a wealth of high-GPA students? Also, colleges do not have much reason to innovate in admissions processes-what is the maximum gain possible from doing so? Not very much, and not very tangible. (I figure if education were for-profit, the incentives for innovation would be much greater, but I have not researched the topic.)</p>

<p>You also have to take into consideration what we are referring to as a low GPA for grad school. A good GPA at a good engeering program could be around a 3.2…i think with even a litlte consideration that you went through a rigorous engineering curriculum would put you up there with some good applicants to grad school.</p>

<p>Grad school, we’re talking about law. That is completely different. In engineering you have pretty much equal difficulty majors applying to grad school but law school has a variety of majors. The thing with law GPA is that they want to see someone as top of the class, b/c that demonstrates a willingness to do so in LS. So if you are at the top of your class in lib arts you will gain a higher GPA naturally.</p>

<p>What law schools don’t take into account is the relative hardness of the ability to stay at top. If you have a 4.00 in engineering you are a genius and wow you are incredible. If you have a 4.00 in lib arts or other major you are somewhere between smart to very very smart indeed (maybe genius) but pure genius isn’t required. That is just a fact. It is easier to do better in lib arts majors because curves arent as steep and the number of gen eds and lower level classes for the first 1-2 years can greatly help a GPA.</p>

<p>What LS need to realize is that a 3.3 is a hell of a lot more valuable than a 4.0 in leisure studies. That 3.3 is much more of an accomplished student in engineering than the other is in his/her major. You can make your majors difficult if you want so dont stand up for your stuff lib arts b/c you can make it easy too. Engineers don’t have that option. There are a few tracks sometimes but these often vary from hard to extremely difficult. And hard routes often lead to following behind those learning more than you.</p>

<p>But to lfk: You GPA is only a factor at LS that are Top 25. They often don’t want to lose their ranking. The Dean at U of I told me he doesn’t often care too much about GPA if your major meant something. He also said he was one of the few that did that. That is probably one reason why U of I is out of the top 25. They take quite a few engineers (for a law school) but take other schools into consideration. Others that aren’t at the top and don’t have a wealth of GPAs coming to them will often throw money at students with similar GPAs but advanced majors. Why? B/c they know that they can get some good stuff by scraping the barrel midway.</p>

<p>Rant: Unfortunately GPA, being a horrible definition of an intelligent student. It only defines intelligence within a subject within a certain situation (your year, your class, your school, grade de/inflation) so it is a very bad way of measuring quality. But it is the easiest way to define things. Ruffles makes potato chips faster, more efficiently, and healthier. Does that make them tastier? Not necessarily. But the profit and process will dominate any loss of customers over taste. Same with law schools. On the surface the shallow GPAs (profits) shine above the rest but are they getting the quality students they could? Probably. Just not all of them. It is more important to be higher in the rankings than retain quality students b/c chances are the LS could just make them quality students because they are somewhat hard-working and most likely are very smart. So if you are logically about it you will realize that law schools don’t need engineers or their GPAs.</p>

<p>I completely agree that rankings play a huge role in what goes on with law school admissions. Another factor, IMO, is ignorance - admissions officers probably all have liberal arts degrees and have no clue what it takes to even graduate with an engineering degree, let alone excel.</p>

<p>My engineering school curved most tests to a 2.5. Yep, folks, a 2.5. So take all of those hypothetical “3.3s in engineering” and put them… yeah, you know. :wink: Less than 20% of the people in my major got a 3.3. Most all of them had 1400+ SATs and were in the top 5% of their high school classes. Try telling that to a law school admissions officer, though. </p>

<p>I challenge any of the high schoolers out there who disbelieve me to go through the experience themselves: take engineering. Take the most rigourous classes available (advanced quantum was one of my electives). Then apply to law schools with a low GPA and try to compete with your liberal arts friends who skated to 3.3s and put a little effort into their 3.5s. Then talk to me about this - but until then, please don’t speculate. </p>

<p>To me, applying to law school with an engineering GPA is like evaluating running ability by analyzing mile splits in a marathon. Law school is like a 10K. All of your peers are using a 1-mile race to get their mile split. Face it - the marathoner can certainly manage a 10k, and of course the mile splits (for 26 miles) are going to be slower than those for a single mile. But oh no, it took the marathoner 8 minutes per mile, while the other people did 6 minute miles. Big question that no one asks: who will be the best 10k runners?</p>

<p>Likewise, if you can handle engineering at a good school, you can handle law school. IMO, there should be a presumption of competence and work ethic for engineers - but I don’t run law school admissions. ;)</p>

<p>ariesathena…you think there is anyway to prepare yourself for engineering…I plan on doing it and I’m good at physics and calc and all that good stuff, but I know its not gonna be easy for me, just like its not easy for anyone else. It make be a stupid question, but do you think there could be anyways to prepare yourself?</p>

<p>Everything I see on this thread I agree with, which is why I support the idea of engineering schools providing ‘pseudo-transcripts’ to their students if they want to apply to places like law schools, where these transcripts eliminate all bad grades and basically provide a boost to their students.</p>

<p>Hey why not? If the law school adcoms insist on playing GPA games with the process, then I don’t why the engineering schools can’t respond in kind. The engineering schools can simply rescale their grades for their students as if they were using liberal arts grading scales for the purposes of making them look good in the law school admissions process. If the law school adcoms refuse to innovate, maybe it’s time for the engineering schools to do so.</p>

<p>I love that idea. It can be like the Harvard prof who gives two grades - the grade he wants to give and the official one so students aren’t deterred from taking his class.</p>

<p>Do I think there is any way to prepare for engineering school? Yes - be excellent at math, chemistry, and physics. Be prepared to work your butt off. I don’t think there is any way to prepare, however. (I would, on the other hand, say that there are ways to prepare for law school - such as reading overviews of first-year courses, legal analysis, etc., during the summer before law school.) </p>

<p>Other views?</p>

<p>hmm…i am excellent at math and physics…that makes me happy…although i havent taken chem since soph year…thats gonna suck. I wanted to take AP Physics II and AP Chem this year, but I couldn’t get into chem cause I wouldve had to change from one packed English class to my Eng teachers other, slightly more packed class (by like 2 studesnt), and the vice principal wouldn’t approve. I think I wouldve been number 35 in the other class haha. So I’m stuck taking AP Euro and astronomy instead.</p>

<p>There is just no way to prepare. I know a lot of people that love the math and sciences in high school and get to college and hate it. I actually hated math and physics in high school (I just liked chemistry but didn’t want to do just chemistry, nothing wrong with that but I didn’t) but I love them in college. I like understanding them. So it depends. I was actually more of an English student in high school everyone thought I was going into film & psychology but then I picked engineering and nobody had any idea. Then I stayed with it and did pretty well and my friends were even more shocked. So just stick with what you like but just keep in mind not to force it, just because you’re good at one level doesnt make it so at the other. If you end up not liking it just move on don’t make yourself miserable.</p>

<p>That is the number one mistake is that people just try to hold on to that last bit of stronghold they had in high school. There are other mistakes. So here are some things to keep in mind. Don’t expect to be teaching the class things. Don’t expect to be number one. Don’t expect to be passing everything. Don’t be afraid to drop a class, a drop is better than a bad grade. One test won’t ruin you. Do all the work and go to all the lecture no matter how unimportant they seem because every point counts. And if you miss one, again, it won’t ruin you. No need to freak out, professors can be scary but are usually reasonable.</p>

<p>Also here are some things to do. Exercise. This will help in multiple ways. I hate watching my body go to waste so getting a work-out buddy to help is key. Start meeting others right away because then you will have homework and study partners. If you have a hard time getting started often a trip to the library with a friend or two (that you know well, so not too much talking has to be exchanged, and any more and it will be too many) to get work done and then you’ll always have people there to ask questions. Get a goodnight’s sleep. Treat everyone nice, you aren’t better than anyone. Alright that’s all the tips I can think of for right now.</p>

<p>Thanks for that IlliniJ…it was good</p>