Which should I transfer to: Swarthmore or UMichigan?

Oh boy. Here we go.

Academics are wash. Both great. Both dependent on you.

Big big campus and great college town. Sports and a bee hive of activity.

Small campus. Outside a big city. Student activist vibe and intensity.

@happymomof1 Not considering. I know exactly what you mean however not the right choice for me. Thank you though for your advice!

@happymomof1 Also, even if I were to take a year off I really wouldn’t be doing anything and time is still money.
Furthermore, it would not allow me to figure out what I really want to study as I would just be at home with my parents or working part-time at a retail store.

Also, you make it sound so easy like oh just take a year off and you’ll figure out what you want to do with your life…it’s not that easy. Regardless, I am sure that at Michigan or Swarthmore I will be able to explore my interests as I am technically only a rising sophomore; I just finished my first year of college. Right now I am leaning more towards Michigan because they offer essentially every major you can think of since the institution literally has 19 schools/colleges.

Swarthmore does, however, seem to make most of its programs and courses widely available to all students in a generally timely way. By four-year graduation rate, as an indicator, it places near the top when compared to all schools nationally.

https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/highest-grad-rate

If you took a year off why would you only work part-time? And why would you pick retail?

My SIL paid $60k/year for both her kids to go to college. Like you, they didn’t know what they wanted to do. They, too, thought they’d figure it out as they went. After four years of college for each kid and just under half a million dollars both regretted their field of study. So the parents laid out similar amounts of cash per year for professional school. I forget the total amount they spent but it’s in the neighborhood of a million dollars. The advantage their kiddos had that you don’t is that the parents could pay out of pocket.

I’m so concerned for you. What if you take out $100k of loans for undergrad but decide that’s not the career for you? Time is money, but time spent on the wrong thing is a waste of both the time and the money. It will be extremely difficult to change course after graduation with that kind of debt. Even if you love the career you choose, why start it with $100k of debt when you can go to a great school for a fraction of the cost?

You’re obviously a very smart young man. There are plenty of schools that would be thrilled to have you. The Univ. of AL is a big sports school and they only cost $44k for OOS. With your parents’ $30k, the $6500 federal student loan, and $3k summer work earnings your gap would only be $4k/year. Even if your parents have to borrow the $4k your total debt would be less than $30k. And AL is a great school. And there are plenty of others.

…obviously a very smart young *person/i

Went & looked at OP’s other posts. WL at UChicago; that, plus current acceptances and strongly dismissive comments about the current university (‘it’s so bad even the profs send their kids out of state to UMi instead of taking the free option’) suggests that between cost (invisible future debt) and prestige (visible right now), the decision will tip to prestige.

Already debt is affecting your plans for the future and you haven’t even taken it on yet.

What do you want in a college besides a name brand? The Univ. of WI at Madison is up north and also has a good football team. I think there CS program is selective though. COA is only $43k, so it’s within your price range and you could probably afford to go directly to grad school afterward if you wanted.

@austinmshauri
The University of Wisconsin-Madison I have also applied before and been accepted. Their COA is now 54k for OOS students.

Yes there are certainly other schools that are cheaper such as U Alabama (as you mentioned), however Michigan is one of the better public higher education institutions in the country and even in the world. Since I am already spending so much money to transfer, I rather spend it on a school that I am really interested in. I never even thought for a split second to go to U Alabama because it was not what I wanted. The only public schools I am interested in are UNC Chapel Hill, UC Berkeley, UCLA, UMich, and UVA. Personally, I like UMich.

UVA is even more expensive than Michigan, UCLA and UC Berkeley are about the same as Michigan, and UNC Chapel Hill is slightly cheaper at 54k a year which is 10k less than Michigan. However, I never applied to UNC Chapel Hill and would not prefer to take another year to apply…and I would still prefer UMich over UNC.

Truthfully, my parents do have the ability to pay for my total cost of attendance. It’s just that my parents want me to understand financial responsibility at a young age, so they will provide 30k to me and the rest I can take out federal loans (Canadian and U.S.), and whatever is remaining I will borrow from them as well as my older brother who is 30 and is a doctor in residency at a hospital in NYC. It is highly likely that I will not have to take out any private loans which is really a dangerous zone to get into.

I really appreciate your concerns and going your way to try and talk some sense into me. Seriously thank you for looking out for me.

But trust me on this, I know what I am getting myself and my family into and am doing everything I can to be prepared for it.

My family and I have really talked about this forthcoming financial impact and overall my family is able to handle this.

Thanks man.

Your physician brother in residency probably does not have much money to lend. Even when he gets a post residency job, his excess income will go to servicing his own medical school debt.

Folks can we stop beating a dead horse here? Really, the OP and family have “underwritten” the financial risk. Let it go.

Michigan or Swarthmore is the question.

@ucbalumnus I am already aware of this thank you. I wouldn’t borrow a lot from him and definitely have taken what you mentioned into consideration as well before making a decision to transfer.

Ann Arbor is a better college town, and Michigan has a pretty amazing school spirit. You’ll have to search out research opportunities and actively pursue what you want. There won’t be anyone to hold your hand at Michigan. and if you can live with those conditions, a Michigan data science degree is likely going to be more marketable than economics.

A career in data science can begin with academic preparation across math/statistics, computer science and social sciences (e.g., economics). Before committing to Michigan on the basis of its data science major, you might want to compare its program to the array of majors and courses at Swarthmore that could offer you excellent – as well as, in consideration of the changing nature of the data science, perhaps less limiting, preparation for the field.

https://www.hamilton.edu/news/story/shauna-sweet-03-shares-career-path-in-data-science

Last sentence not what I wanted based on late edit, but you should get the idea.

Social sciences are not central to data science. They’re just applications of data science in their respective fields. For data science, OP will need the following courses:

  1. Math (linear algebra, probability, statistics, analysis, discrete math)
  2. CS (algorithm, machine learning)
  3. EE (signal processing, information theory)
  4. Some application of data science (e.g. robotics, computer vision, business, economics, or other fields of natural or social sciences)

UMich has a School of Information, would this be considered in the realm of “Data Science”?

https://www.si.umich.edu/content/bsi

^No, but there’s some minor overlap.

School of Information is actually really cool but more end user experience, basic data collecting, prototyping. It actually lists what careers fit this in the link.

For an additional perspective on suitable academic preparation for a career as a data scientist, the OP can search “4 Reasons Why Economists Make Great Data Scientists”:

Re: #78

The economics majors who enjoyed econometrics, chose the more math-heavy economics courses, and chose to take additional math and statistics courses would probably be the ones referred to as potentially good data scientists. But they may not be the majority of economics majors.