Who's applying for Fall transfer 09'-Cornell?

<p>don’t worry, i respect your belief in whatever, but I understand that contention on such issues is useful since it causes you to think and question (ie. from Montaigne essays).</p>

<p>Alright I’m back!
Grats to all accepted! </p>

<p>I, personally, do not believe in religion. But do not mess with other peoples faith. No one is preaching their beliefs on another. There is no need for arguing on whats right and whats correct. Everyone is going to believe what they believe.</p>

<p>OMG!!! This is the best topic that has come up in this thread. Although, I would lean toward the position you hold, your first comment was quite harsh jedi. I have felt like, but restrained, at certain points from saying similar things when people here have referred to all these notions (not even necessarily theistic) of there being some kind of destiny, or fate which guides the directions of our lives (and your getting into, or being rejected from, Cornell).</p>

<p>If you don’t want people like jedi to say anything, don’t say controversial ****.</p>

<p>Please answer these two questions Jedi:</p>

<ol>
<li> Take a look at the door of your room; who created it?</li>
<li> Does the door of your room have the qualities of the person who created it?</li>
</ol>

<p>I’m just saying that yes, it’s great to get accepted, but don’t automatically link that to some supernatural influence. You worked hard, so take pride in the effort you gave.</p>

<p>zakaqel:</p>

<p>Plese answer this question:</p>

<p>What is the purpose of your questions?</p>

<p>(creation in the theistic sense = new matter)

  1. the door wasn’t created. the elements were used by people to forged a “door.” The elements, according to thermodynamics, cannot be created nor destroyed. </p>

<ol>
<li>The qualities of the door resemble the person who helped forge it together, though they weren’t any artist!</li>
</ol>

<p>Message from the CoE Admissions:</p>

<p>I called them this afternoon, and the lady told be the results wouldn’t be released until late next month or even later.
I:" …so you mean around mid-May, like May 15 (the so called ‘magic day’, lol)?"
She:" Oh, no. Probably very late May and more likely in early June. So there’s no result to release currently."
…
Anyway, I don’t remember exactly what she told me, but the decisions will be out very late.
Fingers crossed.</p>

<p>But I’ll answer yours:</p>

<ol>
<li>I don’t know; maybe you do?</li>
<li>This question is ambiguous. You could mean either “Does it have ALL the qualities of its creator?” or “Does it have AT LEAST ONE of the qualities of its creator?”</li>
</ol>

<p>As for the first, no; as for the second, yes.</p>

<p>The door was created(forged? call it whatever you want) by some random human. Likewise, humans, as an element of the physical world, had to be created. </p>

<p>You’re obvioulsy going to respond by saying, “If God created humans, then who created God?”</p>

<p>The door does not have the qualities of the human that “forged” it. Can the door talk? Can the door procreate? Likewise, Humans, who were created by God, do not necassarily have the same characteristics as God. As such, God is not a part of our physical world. Therefore, God can not be characterized using our physical world’s standards.</p>

<p>christian “scientists” use the painting example. If painted, it must have a painter. And that painter is what one might call a “creator.” However, painters merely utilize the physical elements (paint, canvass, water, etc.) and mental elements (ideas, visualization, etc) to produce something. All the elements for the painter are already there. God on the other hand, apparently produces something out of nothing. The problem with this is that something cannot come out of nothing (0 cannot equal 1). This is where creation, and the painter (or doormaker) example, fails.</p>

<p>Nevermind.</p>

<p>Yes, but I told you that God is not a part of our physical world.</p>

<p>Ok. Let’s say God doesn’t exist…where did the matter that composes us come from?</p>

<p>Hey Crescent, looking at your stats, you think maybe the 86 credits might have hurt you??</p>

<p>zakagel, this is a common question, where did matter come from. The simple answer is: from the previous moment of existence -a kind of cause and effect if you will. Simply speaking, most scientists agree that matter is beginningless. Again, this is what thermodynamics makes clear, that matter cannot be destroyed or created, and that it is in constant flux.</p>

<p>The idea that matter was created is just seen as the primitive answer from ancient societies; paired with the lack of science and the encouragement of superstition, creation seemed like a plausible answer to them.</p>

<p>On another note, if god exists outside the physical world, you thenget into the atemporal vs temporal existence argument. It’s a fun argument, but time consuming (I’d have to write a lot).</p>

<p>Wait, you said:</p>

<p>“The problem with this is that something cannot come out of nothing (0 cannot equal 1). This is where creation, and the painter (or doormaker) example, fails.”</p>

<p>This contradicts what you said about matter being beginningless. If matter is beginningless, then why can’t God be beginningless?</p>

<p>I guess 1=0?</p>

<p>that’s a good point zaka. But back to thermodynamics. As you point out, god could be beginningless. However, he would be subject to continual change, as we are -in other words, subject to cause and effect. This would defeat the popular notion that god is immune to causes and effect and human existence.</p>

<p>Hi, </p>

<p>Im a firm believer in religion, and think its a great conversation, but can we please stay on topic?</p>

<p>LMAO…neither one of you have produced a single conclusion which follows from your premises</p>