While you went to a FL HS, did you maintain FL residence?
Many MI specialists in the Army get assigned to AZ, TX, and GA so they change state residency to those locations. You could have been considered an OOS.
Essay may have been an issue. Structure? Grammar? Spelling mistakes? Want me to take a look at it? PM me the essay.
HS profile. FSU may be familiar with your HS. Is it a HS with a profile that suggest grade inflation?