My vote is UNC Chapel Hill. Not that much more expensive than W&M but with the honors program and research opportunities you will be intellectually challenged in a school that is also socially fun. I love Emory main campus but does not sound like worth the extra $$. You clearly worked hard to be given these great options. I say go out of state - fresh start. However, I have a feeling you are on a great path no matter your decision.
3 Likes