If you have been accepted to Princeton, than Princeton, because of the science + creative writing mix. They also have the highest percent of students who end up doing a PhD of the colleges in that list (around 14%, versus Yale 13%, Amherst 12%, Wellesley 11%, Columbia 9%, UPenn 6%, while Chicago and Williams are under 5%).
I am not a big Yale fan, overall, but I think that it likely should be your second choice, followed by Wellesley. I don’t see UPenn or Williams as serious contenders, considering your interests and future plans.