if you look at previous thread, Female applicant for SCS had a 1540 SAT (800 math), 800 Math subject test. 34 ACT. Got into some wonderful public schools but not CMU, MIT, etc. I am still waiting for actual data support the hypothesis that the women being admitted to CMU are subpar.
Btw: The fact that she was admitted to several highly competitive public programs suggests there wasn’t some dramatic flaw in her application, such as negative LoRs.