Welcome to College Confidential!

The leading college-bound community on the web

Sign Up For Free

Join for FREE, and start talking with other members, weighing in on community discussions, and more.

Also, by registering and logging in you'll see fewer ads and pesky welcome messages (like this one!)

As a CC member, you can:

  • Reply to threads, and start your own.
  • Post reviews of your campus visits.
  • Find hundreds of pages of informative articles.
  • Search from over 3 million scholarships.
Home / /
New Discussion

ACT score of 20, stellar everything else. How much will this matter to "average" LAC's?

dec51995dec51995 Registered User Posts: 264 Junior Member
in College Admissions
My nephew is a rising senior. His gpa is 3.8 and he has a long list of EC's: varsity sports, lead in the musical, choir and band participation, employment, church participation (he's thinking about the ministry). He attends a very small (class size of 60), rural public high school. He's been to state twice (in 3rd tier athletic conference) for golf, but his scores don't seem to be drawing golf coaches in division 3 schools. He's found some schools he's interested in, but the 25-75% of each of these is higher than his ACT composite. I'm wondering how much the ACT score range matters for LAC's that aren't in the top 50 USNWR. With a strong gpa, does he need to worry too much about scores that are significantly lower? He's planning to do ACT prep this summer.
· Reply · Share on Facebook
«134

Replies to: ACT score of 20, stellar everything else. How much will this matter to "average" LAC's?

  • dec51995dec51995 Registered User Posts: 264 Junior Member
    Some other things I should add: he will qualify for need-based aid. Right now, the schools he's interested in have an ACT range of 23-30 or so. I'm wondering whether he should be adding schools with a lower ACT range. Thanks!
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • ucbalumnusucbalumnus Registered User Posts: 76,598 Senior Member
    Has he tried an old released SAT to see if he can do better on the SAT than the ACT?
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • dec51995dec51995 Registered User Posts: 264 Junior Member
    No. I imagine his score will be similar on the SAT. He has issues with reading speed.
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • dec51995dec51995 Registered User Posts: 264 Junior Member
    But no LD diagnosis to fall back on for test accommodations. :(
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • StressingMomStressingMom Registered User Posts: 88 Junior Member
    edited June 2015
    I think the issue is that it's very difficult for colleges to gauge a student's "college readiness" by looking at their GPA. There are so many different ways to calculate highschool GPA and a 4.0 at one school isn't necessarily equal to a 4.0 at another school. That's why the colleges look at standardized scores like the ACT and SAT.
    Hopefully his ACT prep this summer will pay off . Or, as the previous poster mentioned, have him do a practice test on the SAT and see if that works better for him. Some kids do better on one or the other. Then again, there are some kids that don't test well at all. I've read about some "test optional" colleges on here, that may be something to look into.
    This is the list I found: http://fairtest.org/university/optional
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • DarkEclipseDarkEclipse Registered User Posts: 712 Member
    I think he should look at a few test optional schools as well, since a 20 is really low.
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • dec51995dec51995 Registered User Posts: 264 Junior Member
    Thanks for you help. I should refine my question a bit. I know a lot about the ACT and SAT tests--I prep students fro them. And I know a lot about the college admissions process for highly selective colleges--have two kids who have successfully pursued top 25 LAC's. What I don't know is how students with nephew's ACT score fair at the "average" admissions level. I know that selective colleges use test scores to boost their rankings, and I know that at competitive schools, test optional isn't necessarily a good choice for students with low test scores because colleges use this to boost their overall test scores while rejecting students who didn't submit scores. What I don't know is how the less selective schools handle things. Has the push for rankings affected even schools with, say, an average ACT score in the 22-26 range? Anyone with personal experience of an "average" ACT composite looking at schools with above average ranges but not "highly selective" ranges?
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • BatesParents2019BatesParents2019 Registered User Posts: 801 Member
    edited June 2015
    @dec51995 I would look at test optional schools. They will however place more emphasis on the quality of his high school and course rigor.

    Where do you live?

    @StressingMom Even colleges that require standardized tests acknowledge they have very little predictive value. It is just a weeding tool. You will see even Ivy League schools going test optional in the near future.
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • StressingMomStressingMom Registered User Posts: 88 Junior Member
    edited June 2015
    I'm sorry, I don't really have personal experience with that.I found this link, maybe it will help a little?
    http://colleges.****.com/colleges/browse/act_composite/results/19-24/19.aspx It breaks it down by Low, Medium and High selectivity. I think your nephew's EC's are great and may help in the admission process. If the link won't work, replace the **** with **** .
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • dec51995dec51995 Registered User Posts: 264 Junior Member
    Thanks, again. I found the site you referenced, StressingMom, but it didn't really make sense to me. (High average ACT scores for the school were marked "low" and low ACT scores were marked "high"--I think it's just telling me what I already know--the score range and how nephew's score compares to the school's range. Yes, his EC's are super. I think high school rigor is low--it's a small, rural school in MN. I don't think this is a case where he's a brilliant student--I think A's are pretty easy to get at his school (and he's a teacher's kid--just sayin'). However, I do think he could handle the academics at a "normal" LAC. Still looking out there for someone out with a similar profile to nephew who applied to a range of average LAC's. Anybody? Anybody?
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • momofzagmomofzag Registered User Posts: 641 Member
    I wonder if @Hanna has worked with any students like this.....she might be a good resource for you.
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • dec51995dec51995 Registered User Posts: 264 Junior Member
    Great idea--thanks--I messaged her.
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • HannaHanna Registered User Posts: 14,902 Senior Member
    "test optional isn't necessarily a good choice for students with low test scores because colleges use this to boost their overall test scores while rejecting students who didn't submit scores."

    ?? This doesn't make any sense. Students you reject don't affect your test score numbers. The only way test optional boosts scores is if some of the students you admit are admitted with no scores instead of low scores. Which is exactly what schools are up to. Test-optional schools are the answer here if you want him to get into the kind of strong LACs that are more likely to meet need.

    As for average LACs, yes, a score below the 25th percentile will almost always hurt a white male applicant, but that doesn't mean he has no shot a school where he's within spitting distance, especially if they aren't that selective overall and if they need men (as almost all of them do). But with a 20, I'd be focusing strongly on test-optional schools. There are lots of them.
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • dec51995dec51995 Registered User Posts: 264 Junior Member
    Thanks, Hanna. There are a number of stories on the net about how "test optional" is to the institution's and not the student's advantage. The line of reasoning is that, if colleges offer test optional admission, only strong students will submit their standardized test scores (which raises the school's average ACT). It will also likely increase the number of applicants--students like my nephew, who are worried about their low ACT's, are more likely to apply to test optional schools. More applications for a limited number of spaces means higher selectivity for the institution. I'd post links, but it's against the rules on this forum, I hear. Presumably, the schools reject students who apply test optional.

    I'd love to hear that this practice--which seems really shady and deceptive to me--is only happening at schools in the most competitive bracket, but I'm a little worried that even the less competitive schools might be playing the ranking game.
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
  • BatesParents2019BatesParents2019 Registered User Posts: 801 Member
    edited June 2015
    @dec51995 I think a test optional school is really the only answer for this student. I also think these stories you read are illogical.

    However, without test scores they will focus on other things such as the student's high school quality and whether his GPA is real or not. Test optional is not a free lunch.

    In what state does this student live?
    · Reply · Share on Facebook
This discussion has been closed.