right arrow
Informational Message Stay on top of the information you need to navigate the admissions process amid the COVID-19 pandemic. We've got articles, videos and forum discussions that provide answers to all of your test prep, admissions and college search questions.   Visit our COVID-19 resource page.

Introducing Kai!
Your College Confidential guide bot.


Kai can provide tips and support as you research and apply to colleges, and explore majors and careers.





Chat with Kai
here, 24/7!


or Skip Forever

Finding the right college for your unique situation can be challenging. Hear from other students who shared their admissions story. Download our FREE Student Voices - vol. 1, Student Voices - vol. 2, Student Voices - vol. 3, and Student Voices - vol. 4 eBooks NOW!
PARENTS4PARENTS: With the deadlines for ED/EA coming up shortly, thumper1 and happymomof1 will be answering questions and sharing their tips on how to build your college list. ASK THEM ANYTHING!
Make sure to check out our October Checklist for HS Seniors. Consult these quick resources to get you started on the process this month.

Jeff Selingo Reveals "Who Gets In and Why" - ASK HIM ANYTHING!

CCadmin_SorinCCadmin_Sorin 2929 replies409 threads Community Manager
edited September 17 in College Admissions
@Jeff Selingo has been writing about colleges and universities for more than 20 years. He is former editor of The Chronicle of Higher Education, a contributor to The Atlantic and The Washington Post, and author of two New York Times bestsellers.

His newest book is Who Gets In and Why: A Year Inside College Admissions was released September 15. For the book, he was embedded in the admissions process at three selective colleges: Emory, Davidson, and the University of Washington, as well as followed a group of seniors and influencers who pull levers on the admissions process that you never see, such as the rankings, the testing agencies, and financial aid consultants.

The book has already been praised in reviews in The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal.

He will help answer your questions about how colleges craft a class and what you can do as an applicant to improve your chances. Ask him anything.

Jeff has agreed to give away a free copy of the book to the first 15 members that ask a question.
edited September 17
149 replies
Post edited by CCadmin_Sorin on
· Reply · Share
«1345678

Replies to: Jeff Selingo Reveals "Who Gets In and Why" - ASK HIM ANYTHING!

  • momartist14momartist14 12 replies5 threads Junior Member
    How much of a role does financial aid play in the decision making process? I am having a difficult time really understanding "need blind" and "meets need." Are students narrowed down to a final list and then, depending on aid, they are admitted based on how much aid is needed?
    · Reply · Share
  • LindagafLindagaf 11444 replies608 threads Super Moderator
    edited September 17
    What are the biggest trends you see coming from the Covid upheaval? Will tests disappear from college admissions at the most selective schools? And, do you believe at some point, when the lines get too blurred, tests might make a comeback, maybe in a different format I.e., a new test might come on the scenes ala the UC system?
    edited September 17
    · Reply · Share
  • wisteria100wisteria100 4633 replies52 threads Senior Member
    edited September 17
    Do some schools have a bar students have to cross for their application to be considered? Like they must meet a minimum gpa, course rigor, test score or their application won’t really be considered?
    And is there some kind of limit for the numbers of students a school will accept from any one high school?
    edited September 17
    · Reply · Share
  • Mwfan1921Mwfan1921 6080 replies97 threads Senior Member
    Regarding where we might end up with test optional, many states still have a HS graduation requirement that juniors/seniors take the SAT or ACT, typically during a school day. In Illinois the SAT is on for this fall for seniors, and again, a graduation requirement.

    Colleges know this, so do you think if students get access to tests this way, that might lead to colleges going back to requiring a test for admission? For example, even this year, Georgetown is only TO for students who don’t have a test score. So, if a student has taken a test (including a state mandated one) they can’t apply TO, and must submit any and all test scores.
    · Reply · Share
  • homerdoghomerdog 9062 replies120 threads Senior Member
    Adding on to @Mwfan1921, our D will sit for the Illinois SAT and it might be the only test she gets. Would it look bad for her to still go TO if that score doesn’t end up matching the rest of her app?

    Also, in regards to need blind, did you get the sense that need blind truly means need blind? One, there’s a question on the Common App that asks if you are applying for financial aid so AOs see that answer and, two, AOs sometimes know the high school well and can make some assumptions that many families there are full pay. Many colleges have a consistent percentage of full pay students and that can’t be an accident. They must seek out full pay students but how is that really done when a college says that are need blind? Selfishly hoping that full pay is a boost even at need blind schools.
    · Reply · Share
  • RichInPittRichInPitt 3000 replies48 threads Senior Member
    How important are AP tests to the admissions process, as opposed to being used for placement after admission?
    · Reply · Share
  • KnowsstuffKnowsstuff 8031 replies39 threads Senior Member
    What makes a successful essay for the student? What are the components of that essay?
    · Reply · Share
  • Thorsmom66Thorsmom66 6 replies0 threads New Member
    How many AP courses do selective colleges expect a student to take? My junior will most likely end up with 5 or so over two years (not available until junior year at our HS).
    · Reply · Share
  • 3kids2dogs3kids2dogs 506 replies27 threads Member
    How accurate do you think schools' C7 Common Data set data is? I'm struck by the excerpt on the Emory legacy/child of an employee who gets a "yes" despite lackluster academics - when academics is marked very important and legacy status is "considered".
    · Reply · Share
  • austinmshauriaustinmshauri 10207 replies393 threads Senior Member
    Jeff, did you work at these colleges? If not, how were you able to gather information about their admission processes? I thought colleges considered their policies (other than the basic admission requirements they post on their websites) as proprietary information. It would be interesting to hear how the book came about and how you were able to gather the information you needed to complete it.
    · Reply · Share
  • lookingforwardlookingforward 35897 replies404 threads Senior Member
    "...promise to meet the full financial need of the student according to their EFC (expected family contribution)."

    It's not the Fafsa EFC. It's as the college calculates per its formulas. This already confuses many.

    Please be aware the answers here refer particularly to 3 colleges. Not all.
    · Reply · Share
  • homerdoghomerdog 9062 replies120 threads Senior Member
    @3kids2dogs i doubt any school will say that legacy is “important”! And we know plenty of kids getting into Ivies ahead of better students at our school because, well, legacy.
    · Reply · Share
  • AguadecocoAguadecoco 333 replies0 threads Member
    Do you think ED will become more important at some schools? And do you feel that will hurt first generation, low income and URM student?
    · Reply · Share
  • 3kids2dogs3kids2dogs 506 replies27 threads Member
    homerdog wrote: »
    @3kids2dogs i doubt any school will say that legacy is “important”! And we know plenty of kids getting into Ivies ahead of better students at our school because, well, legacy.

    Well, all things being equal, sure, take the legacy (or the first gen, desired racial/ethnic status or other "considered" factor). But, it seemed like this candidate wouldn't have been given a second look without the legacy/employee status. Is this common for all "considered" factors. or does legacy hold a special place among them?
    · Reply · Share
  • 1NJParent1NJParent 2580 replies37 threads Senior Member
    3kids2dogs wrote: »
    How accurate do you think schools' C7 Common Data set data is? I'm struck by the excerpt on the Emory legacy/child of an employee who gets a "yes" despite lackluster academics - when academics is marked very important and legacy status is "considered".
    homerdog wrote: »
    @3kids2dogs i doubt any school will say that legacy is “important”! And we know plenty of kids getting into Ivies ahead of better students at our school because, well, legacy.

    ...and none of the schools will say academics is anything less than "important".
    · Reply · Share
  • Mom24boysMom24boys 966 replies48 threads Senior Member
    Are there certain colleges that look for "well rounded students" verses "pointed students" and how do know which is which?

    Do you think students will be less likely to leave their geographic area post Covid and how will that impact college admissions?
    · Reply · Share
  • ucbalumnusucbalumnus 85004 replies758 threads Senior Member
    1NJParent wrote: »
    3kids2dogs wrote: »
    How accurate do you think schools' C7 Common Data set data is? I'm struck by the excerpt on the Emory legacy/child of an employee who gets a "yes" despite lackluster academics - when academics is marked very important and legacy status is "considered".
    homerdog wrote: »
    @3kids2dogs i doubt any school will say that legacy is “important”! And we know plenty of kids getting into Ivies ahead of better students at our school because, well, legacy.

    ...and none of the schools will say academics is anything less than "important".

    From early 2019, CDS C7 / Collegedata.com listings of what admissions factors colleges say they consider very important, important, considered, or not considered:
    https://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-admissions/2131779-what-colleges-use-in-admissions-according-to-cds-listings.html
    · Reply · Share
  • collegemom9collegemom9 826 replies31 threads Member
    Jeff, did you work at these colleges? If not, how were you able to gather information about their admission processes? I thought colleges considered their policies (other than the basic admission requirements they post on their websites) as proprietary information. It would be interesting to hear how the book came about and how you were able to gather the information you needed to complete it.

    The book goes into detail how the book came about and how Jeff was able to get 3 schools that he did not work at to let him in.
    · Reply · Share
This discussion has been closed.

Recent Activity