- Yale
- Harvard
- Princeton
- Duke
- Penn
- Cornell
- Stanford
- MIT
- Dartmouth
- Notre Dame
Pomona #31? nawh…and Berkeley not even in the first #41
I don’t know their methodology, but I put no stock in THIS list.
Shrug…These ratings are meaningless without understanding the methodology. Duke #4, really now? And Cornell #6 ahead of Stanford and MIT? And what logical methodology would rank Amherst #13 but its near twin Williams #63?
What is a “Soka” ?
They soka you for all your money?
Uhhh, not exactly. With a $1B endowment, and only 450 students, Soka now rivals the top Ivies as one of the wealthiest schools in America, on an endowment-per-student basis. Their financial aid is outstanding, which is why collegefactual ranks them #1 nationally in the “Best Value for the Money” category. in the 2017 ranking, USNWR gave them them the #1 “Financial Resources Rank” for National Liberal Arts Colleges (so ahead of Amherst, Williams, Swarthmore, etc).
Average 2015-16 Net Price, from the USDOE College Navigator database:
$18,319 Yale
$18,167 Williams
$17,732 Princeton
$16,695 Stanford
$16,205 Harvard
$12,686 Soka
I can’t access again without becoming a member, but Columbia was like in the 30’s or something.
We live about an hour away from Soka in an area where nearly all the kids go to college. Nobody around here seems to know anything about it unless they’ve seen it in the rankings. Out of about 700 graduating kids each year, I haven’t seen one go there the last 3-4 years.
2018 USA Today/College Factual Rankings
I think these rankings have a little impact because they are published in USA Today. so a lot of parents and potential students see them.
Process
It says that their outcomes are focused on objective outcomes: student loan default rates, early and mid-career earnings, graduation and retention rates.
Ranking 11-30
- Brown
- Caltech
- Amherst
- Northwestern University
- Wash U
- Vassar
- Naval Academy
- Colgate
- Holy Cross
- Vandy
- Harvey Mudd
- Olin
- Claremont McKenna
- Rice
- Columbia
- Middlebury
- Swarthmore
- Washington and Lee
- Wake Forest
- Carnegie Mellon
Sign in with your google account and you can get the full article for free.
Fun to see how different methodologies put different colleges higher! My family loved laughing at me because Williams is 63.
If anyone puts so much stock into rankings that (s)he thinks they are a true assessment of a school’s worth relative to other schools, comparing this one to Forbes to US News ought to help him/her realize that a ranking is just a ranking based on a certain methodology and not the word of a deity.
Soka is still small, they currently have an undergraduate enrollment of about 430, so they only enroll about 110 new students per year. Furthermore, they may well have the smallest percentage of in-state students of any school in California, at 23%. This means that they are only enrolling maybe 25 students per year from the entire state of California.
Olin College doesn’t seem to get the credit it deserves. I work with a lot of Olin students who end up placing in jobs and grad schools very well. Where do they fall in the spectrum here, USNWR and Forbes? don’t hear much about them, and I never heard of Soka before tonight.
@youcee We live about an hour away from Soka in an area where nearly all the kids go to college. Nobody around here seems to know anything about it
So it’s a cult.
While the methodology includes test scores, it does not include acceptance rates. It also gives more weight to full time professors vs part time. It doesn’t include subjective surveys. And while it looks at earnings after graduation, it does it by major, so schools for instance that offer engineering vs those that don’t, don’t get artificially inflated. That, I think is a good way to evaluate that metric.
My nephew applied to Soka. It’s Buddhist I think? Obviously wealthy. Interesting place.
I agree Olin is unique and should get more credit than it does but it’s SO tiny. People who know, know, though. One might be surprised what schools are turned down by Olin kids.
Here’s the methodology for this list -
More details at http://inside.collegefactual.com/rankings-for-better-decisions/
PS: Amherst 13 and Williams 63? This is a GREAT list!!! This methodology is obviously superior to that of all other rankings. anywhere, ever.
(My own college made the top 20 too. Yup, this ranking is clearly superior!)
I did not see how you can customize the list. I only found the filter. Do you know how to do it?
I think that they have some good ideas here in terms of objectivity and letting people customize to reflect what they care about. However, it seems like it misses something in terms of schools that are primarily focused on preparing grads for graduate school. There must be a way to capture that.
Also things like the Amherst vs. Williams difference don’t seem to make any sense. That suggests to me that they need to scrub their data.
Did they calculate their numbers correctly? Why is Vassar ahead of Pomona and Williams?
Here are their components: https://inside.collegefactual.com/methodologies/best-colleges-rankings-overview
Test Scores: Vassar (707 per section, 31.5 ACT), Williams (720 per section, 32.5 ACT), Pomona (720 per section, 32.5 ACT)
Faculty Compensation: Vassar (133083), Williams (138294), Pomona (150408)
Expenditures per Degree: Vassar (233206), Williams (270253), Pomona (300095)
Student to Faculty Ratio: Vassar (8:1), Williams (7:1), Pomona (8:1)
Percent Full Time: Vassar (82.9%), Williams (79.6%), Pomona (78%)
Retention: Vassar (97%), Williams (97%), Pomona (97%)
Grad Rate: Vassar (91%), Williams (94%), Pomona (97%)
Student Default Rate: Vassar (0.3%), Williams (1.8%). Pomona (0%)
Starting Salary: Vassar ($54,500), Williams ($62,000), Pomona ($60,600)
Mid-Year Salary: Vassar ($107,700), Williams ($138,400), Pomona ($130,100)
The only thing Vassar is the best in is percent of faculty which are full time, and it’s listed as low importance.
Seriously, if you look at both it seems Williams ranks lower in “Value for Your Money”, also full time faculty, . You can click through to the college to see how each bit added to the rank. They also rank departments in a way I don’t fully understand.
http://www.collegefactual.com/colleges/williams-college/
http://www.collegefactual.com/colleges/amherst-college/
Or, LOL, “College Combat”: http://www.collegefactual.com/tools/college-combat/#amherst-college~williams-college - this is where you can do lots of personalizing to emphasize or de-emphasize certain factors.
There is also this: https://pages.collegefactual.com/college-matcher/
Soka’s endowment per student ranking was #1 in 2017. In its 2018 ranking that just came out, it dropped to #3. Surprised that Williams went from #12 in 2017 to #1 in 2018 ranking.
https://www.■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■■/college-rankings/details/EndowmentPerStudent