30 Greatest LIVING American Songwriters - Discuss

Should be a gift link. Remember, this is LIVING songwriters. If they aren’t alive, they aren’t up for discussion. Let’s not be old fogies and say “today’s” music is not the same/no good, etc.

And to be fair, many of these are NOT younger people. They are still alive though - as of publication date. :wink:

I’ll :clap:t3: for one of my favorites here - Stevie Wonder. I feel his songs will be know for decades and beyond.

(I debated not starting a new thread and putting it on one of the music threads, but new threads seem to be the rage right now on CC, so here ya go)

3 Likes

Wow, so many legends on this list!

About Paul Simon - I’m so glad “American Tune” was mentioned. I think it’s a brilliant song and the lyrics are so relevant to today. And " My Little Town" - I can never get over how a guy from New York so perfectly captured my feelings about growing up in a fading midwestern town.

3 Likes

And American.

That said, the exclusion of Billy Joel is sacrilege

16 Likes

@skieurope -I agree. Billy Joel should have been included

9 Likes

I’ve already listened to the Taylor Swift interview and currently listening to the three country writers. A little irritated that they lumped the three of them together as each certainly can stand on his/her own.

Finally looked at the whole list. Love the inclusion of Carole King and Willie. A couple of names I don’t recognize.

ETA: I should’ve waited to post until I spent more time with the list. I know Lucinda Williams because she’s an Austin girl, but I had no idea that she was known well enough to be put on this list. I’m sure more thoughts are to come as I keep making my way through it all. Ds2 is a songwriter so this topic is close to my heart.

3 Likes

Tracy Chapman?

Tori Amos?

I just don’t get Lana Del Rey. Ds2 sold her a Christmas tree a couple of years ago, and he called to tell me how starstruck he was. :woman_shrugging: :rofl:

2 Likes

Love that Stephin Merritt made the list! Bruce Springsteen is my go to choice when I think about this question.

I would add Neil Young and Lucy Dacus to the list.

Y’all, in that other thread about songs we love I asid Every Little Step by Bobby Brown. I just learned that Babyface wrote that so, yeah, he def belongs on this list!

Seems a weird kind of bias in these choices. Springsteen is the only actual rock artist represented or did I read too fast?

1 Like

Yes to both. I listen to Amos all the time sms have seen her in concert. She’s fantastic.

1 Like

No, you’re correct. Dylan comes closest with folk-rock, but the list is heavily pop and hip-hop

2 Likes

Saw her twice - in 2000 (?) and recently at the local winery! Amazing how she can play two pianos at once!

1 Like

David Gates, Neil Diamond, Barry Manilow.

6 Likes

Oh, Neil Diamond is a glaring omission. Not just what he performed but what he wrote for others.

Fun fact, he went to high school with Barbra Streisand.

4 Likes

one of the same high schools as Neil Sedaka, too!

3 Likes

How about Randy Newman?

1 Like

Not American though (gibb)

3 Likes

Deleted.

Remember, lists are the product of who made the list and the # targeted do the list. Different producers of the list, and the list looks different. A bigger or smaller # for the list and the list looks different.

We are getting lots of “who is missing”
Who are you happy to see and why??

1 Like