Accepted to a number of Ivy League schools, now financial considerations

There is certainly no such thing as no income off assets substantial enough to retire on and pay full fees at college with, but the way the FAFSA takes your income off the tax return may be what has resulted in this kind of thing. Similar to what OP has said, and I’m in a similar position to his mom it sounds like, just using FAFSA gives us something like $30k expected funding, but using CSS we are totally full pay. It’s something to do with how FAFSA treats the various income categories (taxed/untaxed interest, etc, I’m not an accountant so i can’t explain in detail). FAFSA also doesn’t ask for the same detail on assets that CSS does.

Go to Berkeley. A study co-authored by a Princeton professor found that there is no difference in outcomes for a student who is accepted to an Ivy but chooses to go elsewhere. For instance, a student who is accepted at Penn but goes instead to Penn State will do just as well in life. For URM students, there is a slight bump provided by Ivies and Ivy-equivalents. But for everyone else? Nope. This should not be surprising, as it is the person who makes things happen, not the name of the school. Some schools, yes, can give a boost with a first job, but five years out of college, no one cares where you went to college.

In fact, I politely disagree with an earlier post. If the choice is U of Arkansas on a full-ride (plus stipend) versus getting into serious financial debt (or creating a terrible financial strain on the family) to attend an Ivy, the choice is easy: go be a Razorback!

Your mom has unearned income from investments, savings and whatever else she is living on. They consider her assets. And FAFSA doesn’t “award” you anything per se. it’s a calculation of EFC based on the custodial parent’s financial situation.
I have to agree that what you did is against policy, and if the schools knew, they could rescind their offer. Pick the cheapest and be done.

Hi everyone, let me clarify some things:

  1. I was incorrect earlier, my mom does make some income off of her assets, most of which are tied up as stocks in companies that she used to work at, but that income is small enough for me to qualify for FAFSA. So she isn’t crazy rich to be making six figures off of her assets, but an Ivy is potentially affordable with her savings, also given that my non-custodial parent, who has a substantially higher income, may be willing to split the cost with her.

  2. Yes I did break the rules and matriculated to all of the private schools I got into, after which I deferred my enrollment at each of them for a year. Now that half the year is up I must decide where I will end up going.

Thanks for the feedback

If indeed what you say is true, you are playing fast and loose with the rules – you are NOT allowed to defer at more than one school. If any of the schools were to find out (and they very well could), whatever acceptances you had received could (and, frankly – if indeed you knowingly enrolled at multiple schools – should) be rescinded.

In hindsight I shouldn’t have broken the rules, I feel bad now, I realize that those are in place so that other students can get a spot.

^ You sound very remorseful (sarcasm intended) having deliberately manipulated the system to the detriment of others. I think the behavior is shameful and the thread should be closed. Why would any of us want to support such an unethical behavior. Good luck but be assured such ethical lapses will serve to bite you one day.

" I was incorrect earlier, my mom does make some income off of her assets, most of which are tied up as stocks in companies that she used to work at, but that income is small enough for me to qualify for FAFSA. So she isn’t crazy rich to be making six figures off of her assets, but an Ivy is potentially affordable with her savings, also given that my non-custodial parent, who has a substantially higher income, may be willing to split the cost with her".

Your also playing fast and loose with what you are reporting for FA. There are students out there in “true” need and by distorting your “true” capacity to afford your education you are taking funds from those in need. You have a problem and it’s not which school to attend… it’s a lack of ethics.

I am flabbergasted that the GC enabled and supported this behavior…could also be consequences for GC professionally should anyone find out.

Perhaps you can atone for the unethical behavior by canceling all of your matriculations now.

MODERATOR’S NOTE:

In which case, since it is not our policy to assist users breaking the rules of universities, this thread is closed for ToS violation