Accepted to a number of Ivy League schools, now financial considerations

Hi CC,

Last Spring I was accepted to Duke, UPenn CAS, Columbia and Dartmouth, and surprisingly managed to defer my enrollment at all of them since my HS counselor was willing to send my final transcript to all of them. Now I have to decide between them and UC Berkeley L&S, since I deferred my enrollment there as well. I am very torn between the four private schools, and am slightly leaning toward UPenn, but a financial consideration that has come up is that I will need to pay full sticker price at any of the private schools that I pick. However at UC Berkeley I have encountered a difference in how financial aid is awarded wherein the finances of my non-custodial, higher earning parent are not considered since FAFSA requires the financial information of only my custodial, retired parent. So I actually get a full ride at UC Berkeley as well as a ~$4k grant/semester and ~3k subsidized loans/semester there. However the private schools use CollegeBoard CSS profile which required my non-custodial parent’s financial information, and when I applied with that information they didn’t award me any aid. I called financial aid people at each of those schools concerning my situation and they confirmed that I wasn’t eligible to receive any aid at their schools. So my custodial parent, my mom, will have to pay north of ~$60k/year for me to go to any one of those schools. Finances aren’t a big concern for my mom (she has quite a lot in savings and investments from when she was working, which is why she was able to retire early) (I believe FAFSA awarded me so much because they consider yearly income more than savings in their calculations) but she has brought up the $240k 4-year cost discrepancy (well, more than $240k since Berkeley is giving me a grant) between UPenn and Berkeley and I understand that it might not make sense to spend that much money if I’m getting another option for zero cost. I am interested in Computer Science, for which Berkeley is highly reputable, but I am also interested in business/IB, for which the Ivies are more reputable. On one hand I really want to go to a good private school where I might be given more opportunities, on the other I’m inclined to save $240k. What do you say CC?

Thank you for reading

First, it’s not a loophole. It’s intentional. quote

[/quote]
You don’t get to choose which parent to report on FAFSA. You have to use the one with whom you lived more than 50% of the time last year.

If your retired parent is the one with whom you lived more than 50% of time and indeed you are getting a full ride at Berkeley, go to Berkeley. You want to go into finance. Make this your first important financial decision.

I understand that. I guess it is interesting where to draw the line between smart financial decisions and picking the best opportunity. I guess that given my private school options (which are all phenomenal) it may make more sense to go to Berkeley. However if my question was Berkeley vs Harvard or Princeton, I would say for the record that I would pick one of the latter two in an instant.

You are not supposed to have matriculated to more than one college at the same time. Since Columbia, Dartmouth, and UCB take applications for deferral after matriculation, that means that you are not really obeying the rules (and it would not be surprising if Duke and Penn were similar).

IMO, as someone who worked in IB for years, “business” at undergrad level is an overrated thing anyway. I’m not even sure why you’re debating this - you’re talking Berkeley as your option, not the university of Arkansas. You get a fabulous education, $240k in the bank and better weather at Cal vs Penn. in my mind, that’s a no-brainer. You can always use some of your $240k for an ivy grad school if that’s what you want…

UC Berkeley is a great school. Harvard and Princeton are nice, but they’re not funding you. I would go to the school that footed the bill. There’s a difference between choosing a full-ride at a mediocre college over an Ivy and choosing a full-ride at a top college over an Ivy. I think what matters most is what you do once you get to college–the clubs you get involved in, the internships you get, etc.

Thank you everyone for the input. I am most probably going to choose Berkeley but not without some reservations. I must say that this is a rare situation and that in most students’ cases one the private schools would be the clear choice. At Berkeley I am quite afraid of the massive 30,000 undergraduate population, which is drawn from slightly less selective admissions criteria than the students at the Ivies, and fear that my career advancement may be hindered by a year or two as compared to its progression if I went to an Ivy League school. But currently the financial difference between the schools is too drastic for me to pick one of the private schools.

No one interacts with 30k others. Your dept and peers in classes with you, kids in your dorm or clubs define more.

Qualifying for a full ride means her income is lower. Unless she has millions stashed away, full price can be difficult. UCB is a top school. The same skills are needed to get into business/IB later. I dont see why you project a two year setback. You can get internships all over the country, if done right. SF, LA, Chicago and other midwest cities, even NYC. Etc.

As I stated in the original post my mom is retired which means her income is zero, however she has a nontrivial amount of money in the bank and there is a small chance could potentially ask my non-custodial parent for some funding as well. But $240k is a large sum of money and it seems like it doesn’t make sense to spend it given my circumstances.

If I were you…I will choose UC Berkeley and plan to get an MBA from UPenn. If you want to be in business …an MBA is what will take you higher.

Admissions at any of the schools you are considering, including Berkeley is very competitive. If you attend Berkeley you will be attending school with very bright, smart and motivated students. Do not underestimate them.

It sounds like a no-brainer. Take the full ride and you can use that savings for an MBA. UC-Berkeley is probably the best place you could go for computer science since it’s right in Silicon Valley.

Yes, go to Cal - no brainer.

The glamour of “Ivy” has dazzled you to reality: UC-B will not ‘hinder’ your career for 1-2 years compared to any of those schools- or Harvard for that matter. The students at UC-B will not be overall ‘less’ than the students at the schools you broke the rules to hold a place at. You are mistaken that “the Ivies” are “more reputable” for business/IB: except for Penn-Wharton (which you didn’t specify) the rest are no more ‘reputable’ for business per se.

If you want fame and fortune in IB, then you need to start sharpening your cool, analytical skills, and heed @brantly’s wise advice:

And start working on your summer internships, right from the start. You won’t get Goldman Sachs in first year, but if you play it right, you should be able to get them by summer after Junior year- and the prospects of a job offer after graduation- if that’s still what you want then. That $240K will go a long way to flights & supplementing intern wages in NYC- and for that Wharton or Harvard MBA.

As it happens, Dartmouth, Penn and Columbia comprise three of the ten colleges that Forbes included in this article on expensive colleges that may be worth the cost: https://www.forbes.com/sites/nataliesportelli/2017/04/26/10-expensive-colleges-worth-every-penny-2017/.

However,

You response to this might be helpful, in that at the moment your opportunities seem clouded by it.

I think you need to go back and look at your FASFA. There is no way that your mother’s income is zero. If all of her assets are in covered retirement accounts, I assume that she is taking a distribution that would count as income. If the assets are outside of covered retirement accounts and are significant (>$1mm), passing the Simplified Needs Test would be very difficult.

I agree that something doesn’t ring right. The multi acceptances need explanation and the income issue.

The best of the above advice might be to go with the full ride and then spend the loads of bucks on your graduate degrees. Berkeley is like an Ivy - very selective and very good!

"Last Spring I was accepted to Duke, UPenn CAS, Columbia and Dartmouth, and surprisingly managed to defer my enrollment at all of them since my HS counselor was willing to send my final transcript to all of them. Now I have to decide between them and UC Berkeley L&S, since I deferred my enrollment there as well. "

HUH? YOU can ONLY defer enrollment at the ONE college you have decided to attend- NOT at 6 colleges! THAT ONE college needed to receive your acceptance by the end of APRIL, not 7 months later.
AND, the academic school year at ALL of those colleges began 2-3 MONTHS AGO!
But you are supposedly trying to decide where to go NOW??
Who are you trying to kid?
your post doesn’t pass the smell test. [-X

There is no such thing as an income of zero in retirement. Your mother is living off of something, and that something would be her assets, which provide her with an income.

And if your GC did indeed imply that you were planning to attend each of the schools, then this was highly unethical. Deferments are only granted after you have chosen to attend and have deposited money at ONE school.