Advantages and Disadvantages of smaller schools?

I know this has been discussed before but I’d like to share some observations and see what you think. I used the IPEDS database to categorize schools according to Carnegie classification: Research universities, Masters colleges, and Liberal Arts colleges. This classification has to do with research emphasis and graduate programs but is correlated with size. If there are differences in the quality of student experience among these three types of schools, are they due to size or undergrad emphasis? I tried to control for selectivity by selecting 276 research unis, 72 masters unis, and 172 liberal arts colleges that had the same average SAT for the most recent freshman class available. SAT is highly correlated with graduation rate and I wanted to try to isolate the effect of size alone. The liberal arts colleges had a slight edge in average graduation rates: Research unis = 65.5%, Masters unis = 67.3%, LA colleges = 68.7%. Do you think these slight differences are meaningful? They are based on a substantial number of schools. These three types of schools differ substantially in average size (R=16340, M=4315, LA=1572) and they also differ in undergrad emphasis. What are the operative factors affecting student experience at these three types of schools?

Furthermore, I calculated the correlation between size and grad rate. I used grad rate as an indicator of the quality of student experience. Overall, the correlation between size (full time enrollment) and grad rate was +.30 which suggests that larger schools have higher grad rates contrary to my observation of the grad rate differences among Carnegie classifications which gave a slight advantage to smaller liberal arts schools.

By the way, there is a LOT of variability in size among schools with the same Carnegie classification.

What are your thoughts? Can you help me sort this out? I can’t seem to get my head around this question. Thanks.