Sounds like you don’t have a hook: recruited athlete, legacy, URM, first gen, Posse, Questbridge. High stats, EC and GPA just not enough anymore. You need something compelling about your essays or app. Did you apply ED or EA anywhere? Showing your love might be the only thing one in your shoes can do. ? Let one of the WL schools know they are your first choice and if admitted will attend. Send cookies? sometimes it works.