Am I setting my standards too high?

Hello, I’m currently a junior in high school and I’m not sure of where I stand in terms of college search/admissions. I have a ton of schools that I’m interested in, and even have a more narrowed done list. I’m looking at fairly competitive schools, though I know I’m not anything special in terms of an applicant. I would consider my self a bit above average(in general terms, not in terms of competitive schools), yet I don’t think my grades are that strong or my ECs are significant at all.

A little bit about where I’m looking:

  1. Mostly Boston/Mass schools as well as one or two and VA. I’m originally from an area right outside of Boston, but moved to VA when I was young and have done all my public schooling here, but I’m really interested in coming back up north!
  2. BC&BU are some of my dream schools, but I don’t think I have that great of a chance, and they’re very expensive.
  3. My parents make pretty decent money(still pretty average middle class) but I don’t want them to have to pay a ton of money for an education, nor do I want to be in debt forever. I’m starting to feel like maybe a less prestigious, but more affordable school that I could get scholarships and do very well at may be better?
  4. I know a lot about a decent amount of Mass/NE schools(from cousins) but still feel like I don’t have enough match/safety schools in NE and other places in east coast. If you have any suggestions, please share!:slight_smile:

Below I’m going to share my stats with my projections for this year, I have a pretty good idea about where I think my grades should be at the end of this year, yet no guarantee.

First here are some main things about me in terms of my application:
-White, female
-Parents are from working class Irish/Italian Boston backgrounds/ both vocational hs educated(not college)
-grandpa went to northeastern, but that’s pretty much the only person(beside those of my generation and my aunts/uncles) that went to college (he’s not involved in alumni stuff or anything/ wouldn’t really consider myself a legacy)
-from Boston, raised in upper/avg middle class suburb in VA
-public but fairly competitive and high ranking state high school
-catholic(idk/doubt this will help at BC, but figured I’d mention) also pretty involved in church volunteering & youth groups

Stats/projected stats:
•GPAs without junior year stuff
UW: 3.83 W: 3.89
-got a C in precalc otherwise all As and one B
BTW my school doesn’t weight honors, just APs and +/- don’t count in Gpa just final letter

•Before this year I took 1 Ap (Human Geo) sophomore year and got an A and a 5 on the exam
-also yes I took a foreign lang(spanish 1-4 all As)
-&many honors, just not weighted, classes

•This year I’m taking:
AP Euro: taking exam, A
AP Bio: not taking exam, A
AP Lang: taking exam, A
APUSH: taking exam, very hard at my school on verge of A&B but would be happy with either
Calc(not AP): likely a B
Econ(not AP just grad req): A
Gym(grad req): A
Mass media (yearbook/journalism class that had to take bc fit with my schedule): A

•So;
-w/o A in Apush UW: 3.80 W: 4.0
-w/ A in Apush UW: 3.84 W: 4.03
-w/ A in Apush & calc(highest my Gpa could be coming out of jr year) UW: 3.88 W: 4.07

ECs (as of right now):
•played field hockey for 2 years, stopped this year after neck/back problems
-considering coming back next year, but feel like it might trigger my back problems again, is it worth it for college apps?

•Honors Societies:
-spanish
-social studies
-english
-NHS
may run for leadership positions this year

•Key Club: have about 60hrs currently, not very involved or motivated this year since I’ve heard colleges don’t ever care about this kind of basic club.
-would it be worth it to get back involved?
-not trying to be lazy, just feel like maybe I should prioritize other things

•Spanish club
-considered “founding member” by club sponsor since me (&like 40 other kids) were members the first year

•FBLA (future business leaders of America): we don’t do DECA but we do raise money/ learn more about business and such

•Exceptional Friends: club that meets not very often, helps out special needs kids at school
-my school hosts and we help out a big district wide special olympics type thing

•Part of a volunteer/youth team at my church: fairly involved in volunteering

•Lastly, at the beginning of the year I was really considering starting a NEGU club chapter(helps to raise money&awareness for childhood cancer) I even got an touch with someone from the organization
-I could always still get the club startup approval from and I have many great ideas/ motivated, but I feel I will be very stressed and overwhelmed with my course load
-still willing to start it, considering it means a lot to me, and I really think it could be more than just a typical “I founded my own club” kind of thing
-let me know if you think this may be worth getting into/ may help my app standout!

•Intended Major: Business/marketing

•Also I know I’m just in the middle of my jr year, but I have a good idea for my main essay/personal statement that may help (idk let me know) at Boston schools
-as I said I’m from Boston, but grew up in VA, and would consider myself a strong writer
-I’m not going to share my exact idea, but plan on talking a lot about/tying in ideas about what Boston means to me in terms of the culture/why I want to go back, comparing the diff b/w how I group up upper mid class VA/ compared to my parents big, working class families outside the city & how I want to be the one to come back to Bos/Mass and go to school and become successful
-just thought I’d mention, since it may help at these schools since I’m very interested!

•Finally: I would really like to make a financially responsible decision going into college considering my cousins/older family friends telling my stories and their situations at expensive schools and w/debt, if you could mention schools with good financial aid/ safety or any schools w/ good scholarship opportunities, that would be very much appreciated!!!

If you made it this far, thank you so much!! I don’t have many people to talk to about college apps/search, though I will likely get an outside advisor in the summer.
All responses are really appreciated, and thanks for taking the time to read all about me! :slight_smile:

You won’t if you’ll be competitive for BC or BU, and to determine match/safeties, until you have standardized test scores.

If you don’t want to spend a ton of money on school, you really should avoid anything outside of VA. The only thing Boston gives you is a list of schools you can’t afford. If you ace the SAT/ACT, you could definitely get scholarships, but you’re not going to find them in Boston. It’s a very over represented area where schools are expensive and highly competitive. Scholarships are found in less populated areas like the south and southwestern US. University of Alabama and Univ of AZ are prime examples of generous scholarships to top students.

I don’t see what BU or BC has that UVA does not have, other than a huge price tag. For us, with slightly higher stats BU was tied with Northeastern as by far the most expensive university that either daughter got accepted to. None of us applied to BC.

You are fortunate to have great public schools in-state. My suggestion is that you take them very seriously, then either come up to Boston to work after you graduate, or for graduate school. We will save some of our best snow storms for after you get up here!

Run the Net Price Calculators on BU’s and BC’s financial aid websites to see if they might be affordable.

What is your budget and intended major? Size preference would be helpful too. I can recommend some schools near Boston since I’m from around here and looking at schools nearby, but I agree with other posters that cheapest will probably be in Virginia. Also, don’t do activities and start clubs for colleges, do it because it’s something you are passionate about and want to do.

You are completely right: avoid debt like the plague! You have an amazing array of surprisingly affordable choices in VA, and the Boston area is one of the least forgiving college areas money-wise. Get summer jobs there. Go there for grad school. But stay in VA for undergrad.

My intended major is business/marketing. As for size preference I don’t really want a super small school, besides that I don’t mind, anywhere from a medium/a little small to big is find with me, at least right now. I will say I feel like to small/further from the city, I think I will feel very confined.

Based on your intended major and preference for northerly schools, look into Babson, Bentley, Providence, Fairfield, Syracuse.

In Virginia, JMU should be on your list.

This resource, along with NPCs, can be helpful for estimating expenses for certain colleges: https://myintuition.org/.

Also, I totally get what you guys are saying about VA being cheaper than MA, though UVA seems to get increasingly competitive, and basically anyone who’s even somewhat competitive wants to go there. I don’t know if I’m just doubting myself, but I really think I’m just not competitive enough for UVA. Like I said, I don’t really know where I stand, so let me know what you think, and thanks for all the replies!

W/o test scores, or a sense of where your GPA puts you in your class, it’s hard to say- you aren’t a shoo-in for UVa, but hard to say how much of a reach it is. Where you live also matters- NoVa is more competitive for UVa than much of the rest of the state.

There are a lot of choices in VA, though, & I second the recommendation for JMU esp for Marketing / Business. The two most recent JMU grads I know are working in SF & NYC respectively, doing marketing for super-top tier companies. They got great internships and had jobs waiting when they graduated. Imo, it is under rated in VA, where UVa, W&M & VaTech are the big names.

Not having debt gives you so much more room to take internships / entry level jobs. The recent grad I know in SF was thrilled with her salary offer- until she got out there and realized how expensive it is! But, with a roommate, and no college debt payments. she is living in a pretty decent apartment and being able to do a lot of fun 20something stuff.

I get the attraction of Boston / moving away- just do everything you can to avoid debt. My guess is that you will get a ‘better’ name in VA- but if you have high enough test scores, you might be able to get enough merit aid elsewhere to still manage no debt- so work with your parents now to figure out the numbers.

I think your intuition about looking for an affordable school where you will do well is very sound, and if it is important for you to go back to Boston, why not give it a try? There are a lot of good schools in the Boston area, and you should be able to find one that fits. For example, maybe look at Holy Cross in Worcester? It’s not right in Boston, but close. If neither of your parents are college graduates, you will probably be treated as a first-generation application, which may help. You can try running the NPCs with “guesstimates” as to GPA and test scores and see what they say. We did this our son’s junior year, and it was helpful.

Many people who like BC also are fond of W&M. They share a lot of common applications. Although BC has more exciting sports fandom, they both are outstanding academic institutions and value community involvement. Both have a lot of school spirit. Their students really love being there (from what I can tell after speaking to several from each - lots of traditions) W&M would likely be an easier admit for a VA resident (very tough for OOS). I would really consider that as a great option.

UVA is amazing and has a different vibe than W&M. Decide which one feels more like you. The other VA state schools ahve very good reputations so lots of good, affordable options in VA.

If you are absolutely set on the Boston area and business, you might want to consider Bentley and Bryant (and maybe Babson). Easier admits than BC / BU / NEU. Much easier to get merit. Very strong business programs and great job placement in New England. Bentley is known for having a top notch Career Services group with outstanding resources. Think of it this way, many (probably most) have heightened Career Services within their business schools (literally seperate resources) and far less for everyone else. It’s actually similar resources but spread out amongst the whole school vs. just the B school. With Bentley, the whole school is the B School, so from day 1 they’re focused on preparing you for the workforce. Great if you know you want to be in some business field (lots of interesting majors- far more defined than most schools). Not so great if you change your mind and want to be a history major (any generic non business major - although they have a liberal arts type minor which is popular).