<p>D and I visited Tufts last spring and I made the unfortunate decision to suggest that we eat lunch in one of the dining halls.</p>
<p>I think we at ate Carmichael.</p>
<p>The dining hall was so rundown, dark, dirty, and gloomy (even on a sunny spring day) that it has almost completely turned her off of applying to Tufts. In many areas the carpeting was worn through and had been duct-taped over. In sum, a very depressing experience.</p>
<p>Have there been any improvements or are any planned?</p>
<p>I know there are other option but I think there is only one other “dining hall” on campus. Has that one been recently renovated. What is its condition?</p>
<p>We ate at Dewick during Parents’ Weekend this year and did not notice any of the problems you mentioned. It was sunny and pleasant, the food was fresh and good, and staff was friendly. My son eats almost all his meals there (it’s nearest to his dorm). </p>
<p>We also ate at Carmichael when we toured Tufts but I also did not notice those issues then, either. However, we did notice how happy the students were and how lively and engaged they were with each other. That made such a deep impression on my son that it became a part of his “Why Tufts” essay.</p>
<p>My son eats at Dewick as well since its closer to his dorm. Carmichael is an older dorm But food at Tufts is excellent. My son loves to eat well and he always tells me how great the food is. In fact he was home last weekend and I couldn’t tempt him with any home cooked meals since they have everything at Tufts. Some of his friends went to schools where the food is terrible. So I think he’s very lucky. Not to mention that he’s really happy being there and not just because of the food. When we visited we noticed how happy all the kids were.</p>
<p>My S applied ED to Tufts without once stepping foot in their dining halls or their dorm rooms!!! </p>
<p>He also fell in LOVE with the wisdom of the people, the kindness he encountered, the smiling faces he talked to, the engaged professors…we’ve eaten in both dining halls numerous times now that S is a sophomore and while not gourmet, their meals were quite tasty for a college dining experience, imo.</p>
<p>The people make the college, not the buildings! Yeah, some buildings are older and could use repair, but it’s not that big a deal for us personally.</p>
<p>As an alum, I was blown away by food at Dewick when we visited with my son on Accepted Students Day. The variety of options was amazing. According to Wikipedia, Tufts has been on Princeton Review’s Best Campus Food list since 2005, once in second place. Another college review site gives them an A+ for food.
Carmichael is an older and much smaller facility; if you had asked around I’m sure someone would have told you to eat at Dewick. Though I have many fond memories of Carmichael from the “olden days” ;-)</p>
<p>Is it possible you’re confusing campus experiences with another college? I was in Carmichael last week, and there’s no duct tape anywhere on the floor, and I cannot recall any being there last spring either. It seems foolish to argue with your experience - after all, who better than you to know what you saw - but your description doesn’t sound like either dining hall at Tufts.</p>
<p>I don’t think D ruled out Tufts based on this experience, but unfortunately it did effect her view of the school.</p>
<p>I know we saw what we saw, but based on the comments it seems like our experience is a bit of an outlier. That’s good to hear.</p>
<p>It would be helpful if someone could at least confirm what we saw so we don’t feel like we’re crazy.</p>
<p>I was hoping for something like “yes, Carmichael is dark gloomy and duct-taped but it is scheduled to be fully renovated in 3 months … and all the other options have already been renovated.”</p>
<p>Hi, I have been reading these boards for a long time now and finally decided to create an account. It’s fun.
Actually when I visited Tufts a while back I too saw some taped up area come to think of it. The students were eating and looked happy regardless. That didn’t bother me. I ended up at Duke but my cousin went to Tufts 5 years ago and had only nice things to say about it.</p>
<p>I don’t know when Dewick was last renovated but it looked great; very modern in its design. Large facility with lots of space to move around, dining area had high ceilings with skylights so it was very sunny and bright, and there was additional seating in a loft area.
It’s too bad you didn’t go there or to some other dining facilities like the Mugar Cafe or the Brown and Brew CoffeeHouse or the places in the campus center.
It’s especially too bad if your daughter decides against an excellent school like Tufts because she didn’t like the smallest, oldest cafeteria on campus. But we know students reject schools for all sorts of reasons; mine rejected RIT because he thought the campus was ugly and Union because the tour guide was a total ditz ;-)</p>
<p>myluckydog, I asked my D1 (sophomore at Tufts) for her comments on your post. Her reply:
</p>
<p>One thing I notice is that your original post focused on the ambience but my D1’s response and most of the other posts focus on the quality of the food. What did your D think of the food? Is she more food-as-fuel, or is she more on the food-motivated side of things?</p>
<p>BeanTownGirl - in my four years at Tufts I never ate at Mugar Cafe (or heard of anyone else - undergrad or grad student who did) - is it good? There are some decent options in the Campus Center as you point out.</p>
<p>To answer the original question - Carm’s dining hall is in the basement and only has windows on one side, so it can be dark and gloomy-ish in the parts further from the windows or if it’s dark/cloudy out. The food is still good and I never noticed any duct tape, but I didn’t eat there often.</p>
<p>Dewick was just renovated this summer (I went back over Thanksgiving) and they redid the floors/carpeting, but it was totally fine before that so I’m not sure why they bothered</p>
<p>Tufts had the best food of any college we visited. I’ve eaten in both dining halls and wasn’t particularly bothered by the atmosphere in either.</p>
<p>Carmichael is terrible. Dewick’s menu is bigger. And yeah, recently they just wrote some profane things about a janitor in the Carmichael bathroom… IN FECAL MATTER. Yeah, this is a new low that the Tufts posh student body has reached. So yeah, if you’re ever in Medford, come to Dewick instead… or don’t come at all, we don’t like when you visitors hog up all our seats. :)</p>
<p>I visited a few weeks back and ate at Carm. Even thought it was a bit dark, everyone seemed really cheery and happy–a group of students even invited me to eat lunch with them! The food was amazing too, way better than some of the food I ate at other colleges. Hope that one experience won’t spoil Tufts for your daughter! Tufts is truly an amazing school!</p>
<p>I find this Carmichael “duct tape” mystery fascinating. I’m not questioning what LuckyDog saw, but I am at a loss to explain it. As an alum and a parent of a current student, I have eaten at Carmichael 3 or 4 times in the last two years and at Dewick once or twice. I have never noticed worn carpeting or duct tape at Carmichael and neither has my child (who currently lives uphill next to Carmichael). For other alums out there, the dining hall in Carmichael has been totally remodeled (not sure how long ago) in an art-deco motif. I would in no way consider it “dingy” (see the picture in the link below and draw your own conclusions). There definitely are parts of the dining hall that can appear dark, though. This is probably due to the fact that it has low ceilings and it only has windows on the side that faces northwest. This would tend to make the amount of natural light that enters the room vary based on the time of day and since the windows on that wall are very large (I remember it as almost a wall of glass) it could also make the side of the room furthest from the windows seem the darkest on the brightest days. </p>
<p>Since I am a “natural light junkie”, I just chose to sit near the windows and I found the ambiance quite enjoyable, the food amazing (by college/university standards) and most importantly, the people were as friendly and unpretentious as when I was a student. </p>
<p>Kudos to the admissions staff for maintaining the core culture over all the years!</p>
<p>Here is a link with a picture of Carmichael that will give some interesting insights on Tufts culture and the Carmichael vs. Dewick debate.
[Carmichael</a> | Stuff Tufts People Like](<a href=“Private Site”>Private Site) </p>
<p>Here is a link with a list of some of the renovations from the latest fund raising campaign. It has Carmichael listed, but I do not know if it included the dining hall. I know South Hall also had some renovation work done last summer.
[Giving</a> to Tufts - The Stage is Set](<a href=“Brighter World | Tufts Alumni”>Brighter World | Tufts Alumni)</p>
<p>My curiosity has been piqued. When I bring my daughter back from winter break I will try to remember to pop into Carmichael and look around.</p>
Tufts is truly an amazing school!</p>