Looking for a school for my youngest. Great student, but not a uniquely amazing one. Seeking a great cost effective consultant who knows schools and help us short list our effort. Seeking to boil the ocean down to:
Three great safety schools that are better than Alabama and will give half to full tuition for net cost of 20k or less…starting point is U of Arizona and ASU
Three much better schools he’ll get into where net cost will be 20k-40k
the Stretch schools he can get into and will likely not get any merit
Student has 34 ACT he didn’t prepare for and if it matters can study and raise to 35 likely, maybe 36. 4.0 uw/4/68 w
State Champion National Economics Challenge, 4th place State in FBLA Economics , All Suburban St Louis concert band…4 years of Symphonic, 4 years of Jazz Band, 1 yr math, NHS, Rho Kappa…only leadership position is in FBLA…minimal and non distinguished service
ANyone have a consultant that can maximize a good but not distinguished “Hand?”
Before paying a consultant, you be get some basic questions answered on these forums at no cost.
UA and ASU have published scholarships for stats that you can look up. State of residency?
What is considered "much better"? Also, most competitive merit should be considered "reach", even if admission to the school is "match", "likely", or "safety".
Be sure to check if the non merit schools are affordable by using net price calculators. An application to a school with no chance of affordability is a wasted application.
There is no consultant in the world that can tell you with any certainty what stretch schools a kid with your child’s stats will or will not get into. And if one does promise you, run, don’t walk, away from him/her.
ETA - sounds like this is not your first rodeo with a high-stats kid. Honestly, a few hours of poking around on CC and a thread with exact details of stats/wants/price constraints/state of residence would probably yield as good of a list as hiring a private counselor. Obviously, you may want the counselor as a go-between, though. Good luck - sounds like you have very accomplished kiddos!
intparent, do you mean the College Confidential group or are you a consultant? I had great results with College Confidential the first go around 4 years ago!
We are in MO, not liking our state schools. I have the UA (full tuition) and ASU (half) scholarships and am looking for some safeties that are stronger schools. I have one at ASU Barrett now..was right school for him and we love it. #2 has a little more horsepower despite not being the National Merit Scholar the first is.
Much better would be a school ranked in 40 to 80 let's say and that awards scholarships but cost more and net cost after some merit is likely 40k or less.
I don't think we're going to get any financial aid. Investment in limited partnerships aren't protected in investment plans and income isn't high enough to make writing checks easy, will still be too high to get need worth being concerned about. If son can get in a school where the $ are worth the investment, I'd prioritize. Not sure he has a path to getting into a top 20 given good student non differentiated from other white males. Wrong era for him likely.
GnocchiB, you’re right on several fronts…not first rodeo and likely will find what I need here. without a good recommendation, I will do that. But will invest if the value is there. That said, I Hired one of the national firms first go around and thought I was teaching them so won’t do that blindly again. Talked to a very wise former director of admissions and was impressed until she asked for $15k. Hoping to find the school fit that wouldn’t have figured out on my own and a board like this certainly is great leverage.
As for kids…the first was brilliant and not driven. The second is driven and bright but work ethic is his game changer.
We’ve tried to steward what we have been given…for most part, things have worked out for them…and there are days where I wonder if they ever listen:)
ucbalumnus…really great questions…and not clear cut…much work to do on that front…likely business/economics…still urging him to explore undergrad in engineering as he was the Rensselaer Medal winner at his school for Math and Science.
His preference is “no snow” but that’s because he’s been back to MInnesota for Christmas with me:) For right school, he can learn to wear a down coat! That said, more moderate temp schools are great. He visited his brother at ASU multiple times and that size didn’t seem to be concern AND I’m a fan of smaller where teachers know the students.
Rice & Emory are two to consider. University of Richmond for business. Wake Forest University.
Ohio State offers merit scholarships. Also, if I recall correctly, SMU offers merit awards.
Indiana University–Kelley School of Business offers lots of merit scholarships.
Does he want a dominate Greek life social scene ?
@RedbirdDad: I would love to read of your impressions & of your son’s experiences at ASU-Barrett Honors College. If willing to share, please respond via PM.
P.S. How do you rate your son’s interviewing & interpersonal skills ?
Publisher, great recommendations. SMU, Rice and Emory are on the expanded list of 30 and have been. Richmond was suggested earlier and I can really see that being a fit. Wake Forest crossed my mind only in the last days. Ohio State is tough for a Minnesota Dad:) I think if he was going to school in Ohio, we’d go smaller and try for scholarship at Miami of Ohio (we are doing that) or paying the full fare at Case Western.
As for Greek, it’s possible. I’m a Sigma Chi and former IFC President. Not my decision. Depends on campus and the chapters. Been disappointed on previous experiences with chapters. Despite my own youth, I’ve raised non-drinkers who aren’t going to stray. Not a chance. A social environment where booze isn’t the draw will be a good fit. One with any tolerance for drugs is going to be a big No from him. A chapter that still hazes is a non starter for Dad. Long answer to…I hope we find something that fits and he’s interested but those are going to be his calls that aren’t on his radar yet. Miami of Ohio would be great greek campus from what I can tell, for example.
University of South Carolina Honors College. Great programs in International Business.
University of Miami awards merit scholarships.
If your son is willing, then retaking for a 35 or 36 should help.
If Catholic, then consider Seattle University for a full scholarship. Can get interviews with Microsoft, Amazon & the other 4 or 5 major international located in Seattle. Lots of small high paying firms as well that do consulting work for the major corporations in the Seattle area.
If super preppy, then Washington & Lee in Virginia is worth consideration. Offers scholarships.
If willing to be full pay, apply ED to Williams College or to Amherst College. Consider Northwestern if willing to be full pay & to apply ED.
Seems like he would want a campus where there is a choice to join a fraternity, but the social scene is not dominated by them (i.e. he can have a good social experience if he chooses not to join a fraternity).
https://www.collegedrinkingprevention.gov/media/Journal/082-Presley.pdf describes some factors associated with colleges that related to the level of drinking. Of course, individual colleges may vary compared to what their characteristics may otherwise suggest. Factors associated with lower drinking:
Historically black college.
Black and Asian students.
Women's college.
Less/no fraternities/sororities.
Students not in fraternities/sororities.
Students not in athletics.
Two year college.
Living at home/commuting < off-campus < on-campus < fraternity/sorority.
Larger college.
College in west or south regions (*not* in north east or north central regions).
Publisher, Northwestern is on list of schools to pay for but will take a lot of great positioning to get him in I fear. U of Miami scholarship is a target and attainable. Not a preppy kid. Seattle has far too many rainy days for him and is way too liberal for his tastes. He had a Ben Shapiro birthday cake when he was 14:)
ucbalumnus, laughed out loud when I saw “factors associated with not drinking” that mentioned large schools in the South. Large schools in the south with football added in appear to be the definition of schools that drinking is part of the culture. Hope you laughed. I did:) Not against drinkers or drinking…my kids don’t but they can hold their own with people that do. Just needs to be environment where they are respected for what they believe. A Greek house, even if it’s not my National, that doesn’t have alcohol/drug/haze/disrespect women culture would be WONDERFUL experience I’d be 100% behind. And a chapter, that has alcohol culture but more than that (in good way) still will be fine. Other points…drug/haze/disrespect women/ethnicity …that won’t work at all for him.
Kid similar to mine. I would google “84 Colleges with Full ride scholarships” and read up on those schools. Not all of the awards are offered any more; schools are getting tighter these days. My son had two full ride schools that no longer offer the awards automatically, and the full rides there are now rare. He also got a half ride at Tulane. Money also on the table from Fordham and Penn State (not much from PSU). Got in ED Rice which ended the process. Not a dime from them, however.
I would look at W&L and Davidson as well as Richmond for merit. I really liked Davidson. I think UTDallas, SMU worth looking into. TAMU, if he likes big. In addition to UMiami, Miami of Ohio is a school a lot of kids like. Michigan Stateb gave out some decent money to kid’s classmates. The Catholic schools, other than the most selective ones, often give out nice awards for males with his profile. U Rochester gives money, I know. Cornell ILR looks like a good reach school for him.
I live in an area where college consultants are de rigueur. I don’t think the best of them are as good as this board in coming up with good merit and Fin aid options.
cptofthehouse…not only are our kids similar, our tastes are. Considered Tulane, but don’t think it’s a culture fit.
Davidson comes up as thought every time Steph Curry has a big game:) Richmond just showed up 3 times today as great possibility. SMU, TA&M, Miami of Ohio are probably in top 10 right now and Rice is on list for reach schools. Cornell is something I’ve been wondering about and I just called a young employee of a client to ask about his experience in industrial engineering there. Given the size of class, it seemed like perhaps the best IVY reach, though Wharton would be the dream. I looked at UT Dallas for son 1…wasn’t feeling it for him, maybe time to recheck. Boy did they give out great Nat Merit package. Considered Michigan State and don’t feel it…though I logically had same thinking track.
What Catholic schools are you thinking? Looked into U of Dayton but don’t think it will be top 10. Any other recs, especially Catholic schools? Your list is really great. W&L came up a couple times today. Not a top of mind school for me…maybe too preppy for my kiddo but obviously great.
He sounds like a good fit for Rice and Emory. Rice does not have Greek life, but Emory does. Rice and Emory offer some merit. Be aware that the application date for Emory’s merit is pretty early but all you have to do is check a box. Is WUSTL too close to home? It also gives some merit. As a male he will have a better chance of getting into Emory than a female as its ratio is about 60/40 female/male. The same holds true with Brown and many LAC’s. Rice gets a few more male applicants than female, but ends up about 50/50 in the entering class.