Applying to a school with my "fit" or to a school with better rankings for the major?(ED)

Hey guys,

I know its really early for me to be already thinking about my ED school but I’ve been lost in thought about this lately. I understand that ED is a binding agreement with a school and generally has higher acceptance rates.

All my life I’ve countlessly run into people that made me love the school more as it was predetermined for me to meet them:

  • Had two cousins attending WashU when I was younger and the stories they told me were my first exposure to ‘college life’ and are currently constantly helping me with my college application processes
  • Met a teacher at a summer camp who recently graduated WashU, got to know her (not super personally), talked (a lot) about WashU whenever there was free time and was the person that started me to like reading books again
  • One of my senior’s friends currently attend WashU, talked with her a lot about their financial aid systems and general school life
  • a few more people, but you get the gist.

Every time I talk about WashU to a person I can’t help but fall in love with the school more; I love how the school is midsized, great undergraduate research opportunities, amazing campus, great food, a lot of student support for changing majors, great internship opportunities, lots of career fares, and a plethora of school organized activities like Wild and Thurtene.

I took a peep at the curriculum for my prospective major and the schools teaching style is just what I want: hands-on team and project-based activities, plenty of office hour opportunities, doesn’t normalize test scores, and will probably be able to develop a great student-teacher relationship that pretty much the backbone to my high school career so far.

My only concern is that I’m planning to apply for Mechanical Engineering. I initially neglected Engineering as a possible career path for me because I stubbornly didn’t want to take the same path as my father, fear of coding, and mulishly percieved the maths to be “too nerdy for me”. But after meeting and talking with a few Engineers, I quickly started liking it and fast forward to my late high school years, I’ve never felt clearer that Engineering is the major for me.

I want to apply to WashU for ED because I love the school and its quite a reach school for me. But rankings wise, it’s not the highest (still high nonetheless) school for Engineering. I’m kind of ‘second-guessing’ myself if WashU is the right school for me because applying ED would mean I wouldn’t be able to see how I could have fared against schools with better Engineering programs like UMich, UIUC, USB, or Purdue and potentially have the liberty to be able to choose like most RD applicants. I’m hesitant to apply ED for Cornell as its probably impossible for me to get accepted in RD

In terms of costs, my parents have told me to worry about that later.

Has anyone here gone through something similar like this and if so, could you opine? Any advice is helpful, no matter how subjective. I’m still semi-new to the college admissions processes and have the stubbornly typical “better ranking = better school, lower acceptance rate = better school, If the schools good I know ill do good” mindset.

I’m probably going to be pursuing a masters in Engineering, not sure if this matters/ changes anything.

Do yourself a favor and eliminate Michigan, Cornell, Berkeley and all those other contenders, using criteria that make sense to you, before applying anywhere ED, or you’ll be second guessing yourself come December. If rankings are important to you, then all the finger wagging in the world isn’t going to change that. Factor it in and go on with your life.

For engineering, you just need an ABET accredited program. After your first job, no one will care where you graduated from, as long as you have that ABET accredited degree.

Stories about WashU are not enough to pin all your hopes on with an ED application. Please visit any potential ED school.

If you’re applying this fall now is a great time to consider costs. You should really know how much your parents can pay per year before you apply, especially if you’re applying ED.

“In terms of costs, my parents have told me to worry about that later.”

I think that you should run the Net Price Calculator, and show the results to your parents. You will need their help to run it. However, the reality of facing a cost of $76,000 for next year, increasing at 5% per year, might wake them up. Also, for engineering, and in general, it is probably a good idea to not have a disaster if things stretch out to 5 years. I would figure that 5 years could run about $400,000. One good thing about engineering is that unlike some majors at least there is likely to be a job waiting for you on the other end (assuming that you stay with engineering, which cannot be certain at this time).

“Please visit any potential ED school.”

I agree with this also. I would not apply anywhere ED unless you are sure it is where you want to be.

That seems to be a setup for disappointment later when they tell you there is not enough money to attend your ED college or any other colleges that admitted you.

Get assurance now that they can comfortably pay for WUStL and any other colleges you are considering ED for.

You should apply ED to the school that if offered admission you would never turn down. ETA it should also be the school that is affordable after running the NPC.

Sounds to me that you want to see your options. Nothing wrong with that! There is no rule that says everyone needs to apply ED. My D didn’t.

  1. You don’t have to apply ED anywhere
  2. If you are a resident of Washington, and have good GPA/SAT, do you need to apply ED?
  3. If UW is your state school, then great. If not, take a hard look at your State U for engineering.
  4. As was mentioned, ABET accreditation is the most important thing for engineering schools.
  5. For UW, take the total cost of attendance (In state or OOS) and ask your parents: Can you afford this? or should l look at schools where I could get a scholarship?

You may want to evaluate WashU for Mechanical Engineering objectively, not looking just at rankings. This can be hard for someone in high school, but you mentioned that you father is an engineer, so he may be able to help. Questions you want to ask are:

  1. (easy part): What is the faculty size? Now, schools like Purdue, UMich, and UIUC have very large departments, and WashU will certainly not compare, but very small faculty can create problems in running the entire curriculum well
  2. Look at course offerings across schools and see if there are specialization options or electives that are or are not available. For example, in computer science, some schools will have multiple electives available in each of areas like graphics, security, and AI: so, if one develops interests in one or more these areas, they can go in depth even as an undergrad. Other schools will not provide such an opportunity.
  3. See if you can find placement information, and compare the type of employers offering jobs.

In addition, one suggestion I will give is to look at other mid-sized research universities that are better ranked for Mechanical Engineering: for example, Northwestern (possibly Rice, though I am not sure if its Mechanical program is highly ranked).

Per another thread by the OP s/he is South Korean so no home state.

^OK, that explains a lot. Rankings seem to be a bigger concern for internationals than for Americans.