Applying to Harvard EA with one C+

<p>Hi,
My D (senior) is thinking of applying to Harvard EA this year, she has good stats, EA, and awards. The main issue I see is she has one C+ in one quarter during her junior year in Multivariable Calculus, her overall grade in this course for the entire year is B+. I’ve been studying last year stats for Harvard admissions and most of the students got in EA are 4.0. Following are her other info, based on this, is it a good idea to apply to Harvard EA? </p>

<p>Unweighted GPA 3.9
AP Courses (US History(5), Euro(5), Calc BC(5), Chemistry(4), Lang/Comp(5), now she has AP Scholar with Distinction)</p>

<p>Senior year(AP Micro, AP Macro, AP Physics, AP Psychology, AP Physics, AP Stat, CIS Spanish, CIS Comp)</p>

<p>ACT 35 (one sitting)</p>

<p>SAT 2280 (one sitting, planning to take one more time)</p>

<p>SAT Subject (US History 770, Math 750, Lit 790)</p>

<p>PSAT 225 (she will be a semifinalist)</p>

<p>National Awards (Silver medal in short story in Scholastic Art and Writing, NCTE award for superior writing, and Bronze in National Spanish Exam.)</p>

<p>Regional Awards (Two gold keys, three silver keys, one honorable mention for writing, one gold key for photography in Scholastic Art and Writing) </p>

<p>State Awards (Quarter Finalist, Semi Finalist, all conference award in Debate)</p>

<p>Leadership (NHS, President Debate team, Senior editor literary magazine, Senior editor school newspaper) </p>

<p>EA (Debate, Speech, writing etc, She is a good writer, maintains her own blog and has been writing since her middle school)</p>

<p>Community Service (She has been volunteering for a non-profit since she is in 6th grade and became a student coordinator from 9th grade) </p>

<p>Thanks</p>

<p>

Even with that C+, her stats look fine; GPA and test scores are certainly within Harvard’s range, but her EC’s look very similar to hundreds of other applicants. So it will come down to how an Admissions Director “feels” after reading her teacher recommendations and essays – and those factors are subjective, so who knows. I don’t see her being rejected, but there’s a good probability, as there is for most applicants, that she will be deferred. If you haven’t already, please read this thread <a href=“Chance Threads - PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING ONE - Harvard University - College Confidential Forums”>http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/harvard-university/1420290-chance-threads-please-read-before-posting-one-p1.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Gibby, thanks for the quick response. I did read that link you mentioned in your post, in fact I read several of your comments and advises in this forum.</p>

<p>She has a good EA with her non profit, I didn’t elaborate it. Since she is a good writer I am sure her essays will be good too. But as you said now and in many other threads its all subjective and we’ll see what the adcom decides her app.</p>

<p>They don’t see quarter grades - only final year grades.</p>

<p>

Totally depends on the HS.</p>

<p>I don’t think the C+ is a reason not to apply EA. Many transcripts don’t even show semester grades. So, it may not even be seen. Secondly, Multivariable Calculus as a high school junior is extremely advanced, especially with her interest in writing and debate. @Gibby comments are correct about acceptances. Give it a try.</p>

<p>@Gibby I am newbie to this forum. Read several of your posts and advises in this forum. My son is planning to apply to top schools next year. In some threads I read that kids with national/state awards increases the changes of getting into Harvard and other top schools. I am curious to read your comments that the applicant might be deferred, do you think the national/state awards wont help in the application process? My son is into writing and he is a good writer, what are all the things he can do to improve his chances next year?</p>

<p>Thanks for your comments and advises that is helping several people like me.</p>

<p>HYPS have all publicly said “We don’t admit kids in the SCEA round that we wouldn’t take in the RD round.” That’s Admissions-speak for “We admit the best of the best in the SCEA round.” Typically that means having a GPA that is in the top 1% to 2% of your high school’s graduating class, very high test scores, interesting EC’s, stellar teachers recommendations and thought provoking essays. And even then, the applications process is very subjective. If you don’t have the absolute “full package” usually Admissions defers an applicant to the RD pool so they can better compare them to a broader range of students.</p>

<p>Although Harvard is taking many students in the early round, they are also deferring large numbers to the RD round. Last year, for example: <a href=“992 admitted under Early Action — Harvard Gazette”>http://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2013/12/992-admitted-under-early-action/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>

</p>

<p>@mnaaa001, it’s not that I don’t think national/state awards won’t help the OP, my comment reflected the fact that the majority of applicants, while being well qualified, are deferred in the SCEA round.</p>

<p>Thanks to everyone responding to my original question. I’ve one more question to ask, how top colleges calculate the GPA? Do they take only the honors and AP level courses to calculate their own GPA (academic index) and compare with all other applications? If not how do they rate students who took tough courses vs other students.</p>

<p>@skieurope, can you explain more on your comment “Totally depends on the HS”</p>

<p>^^ Every college does it differently – and they don’t disclose how they individually do it. Some use the GPA exactly as it appears on your transcript, others recalculate it using institutional formulas. See: <a href=“http://www.possibilityu.com/how-calculate-your-“real”-high-school-gpa”>http://www.possibilityu.com/how-calculate-your-“real”-high-school-gpa&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>@Gibby, what is the GPA shown in the following graph? It says “self-reported unweighted GPA”, is it the GPA shown in the student’s transcript? If it is, then it doesn’t tell much about the student’s course rigor.</p>

<p><a href=“The Harvard Crimson | Class of 2018 By the Numbers”>http://features.thecrimson.com/2014/freshman-survey/admissions/&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>^^ As the data features self-reported GPA, I would imagine it’s the GPA reported on the student’s transcript. So, no it doesn’t tell much about the rigor, but rest assured, it’s Harvard – most admitted students do not have basket weaving courses on their transcript!</p>

<p>

Each high school prepares its transcripts according to its own standards. Some transcripts will only show final grades, others semester grades, still others, quarter trimester grades. There is no universal format.</p>

<p>The “self-reported unweighted GPA” on the Harvard freshman survey is just what it says: self-reported. For my son only his weighted GPA was reported on his transcript. He had to figure out his unweighted GPA on his own. He included all his courses. I think different students may have calculated their GPAs differently. Furthermore, GPA doesn’t translate well outside of the context of the school. For example, some schools, or teachers, give out A+ grades and other schools, or teachers, don’t give out anything over an A. But the mail point is Harvard’s attendees, in general, have excellent GPAs.</p>