Are my choices realistic?

I have a 4.0 GPA, with an SAT score of 1420, and an ACT score of 30, although I’m receiving my new ACT scores soon, which I’m pretty confident on. I’ve taken pretty much exclusively AP classes, plenty of volunteer hours in Key Club and my school’s student council throughout 3 years, and I have amazing letters of recommendation from my teachers and councilor. I don’t expect to get into the top, most selective Ivy Leagues. My reaches are Cornell, Carnegie Mellon, and Brown, my targets are NYU, Notre Dame, and Rice, with NYU being my top choice, and my safeties being Stony Brook, Syracuse Uni, and Pepperdine. Do they seem realistic targets?

Yes except Rice and Norte Dame may be closer to reach. But, you have 3 good schools which are safeties for you. As long as the financial aspect is not an issue, you should be in good shape.