Are the 2 close? What is better

Is rose-Hulman of Florida tech compare to each other’s for mechanical engineering

Both are ABET accredited so should have comparable programs.
http://main.abet.org/aps/AccreditedProgramsDetails.aspx?OrganizationID=315&ProgramIDs=
http://main.abet.org/aps/AccreditedProgramsDetails.aspx?OrganizationID=746&ProgramIDs=

What are your criteria for “compare to” and “better”?

Yes, any ABET accredited school will have “comparable” programs in terms of courses, but that doesn’t make MIT and Capella University “close”.

Fairly speaking, these schools attract students with different levels of academic preparation. Looking at, in particular, SAT math scores, RHIT registers a middle-range (660-780) equivalent to that common at academically rarefied colleges. Florida Tech, for its part, logs in at a marginally overlapping, but substantially lower, 580-680. However, It’s really for other reasons – most notably, RHIT’s breadth of engineering programs, including mechanical, that have long been recognized for excellence – that I’d say makes it the stronger choice. The SAT comparison just makes the contrast more visible.

Florida Tech is near NASA and space industry contractors, is quite a bit bigger than RH (about 3500 on campus compared to 2000), has a bigger grad program than RH, and has Div 2 sports. While most Florida Tech students are in STEM subject, there is a big psychology department (with an autism focus - Doug Flutie is on the board) and a business school. Florida Tech has a lot of international students and those do account, in part, for the lower test scores (English may not be their first language).

Florida Tech is on the beach (spring break weather all the time). Rose HIllman is in Indiana (last year hosted the Polar Vortex).

Honestly, before my daughter started looking for schools we’d never heard of Florida Tech OR Rose HIllman, but she’s never run into an engineer who doesn’t ‘know’ Florida Tech. If she had a complaint about Fl Tech, it is that after a year it seemed too small so I know she wouldn’t have been happy at RH. She sure did love the beach, though.