<p>Well, it’s a bit not-so-simple as that.
I agree many third (or lower) tier schools would be thrilled to get an app from a 2300 kid. And, I feel many third tier schools have good programs- that’s where so many of the wealth of PhDs (or PhD candidates) wind up, after all.</p>
<p>But, finding the right “fit” for your 2300 kid’s interests is not always as simple as getting in. Sure, plenty of state schools have broad, intersting programs, good facilities in sciences and etc- and enroll plenty of high-performing kids. Not true at all the smaller schools (“the other 2400 colleges”) that routinely accept 1500/2400 and B-/C+. And, while it’s nice to be a big fish in a lttle pond, many kids perform best as a medium fish in a more challenging pond.</p>