<p>It is true that engineering is not highly respected in the US. However, to me, the problem doesn’t really have anything to do with educational standards or initiatives to foster engineering knowledge among the kids. It’s really a matter of priorities and demand. The fact is, many American kids don’t learn engineering because they don’t WANT to learn engineering, and the reason why they don’t is because they don’t think the payoff is good enough. What many kids want is what they see on TV, and what they see on TV is that the way to quick success is through pop culture. None of the kids in my neighborhood want to become engineers, instead they want to become the next Lindsay Lohan, the next American Idol, the next LeBron James, the next Usher, the next Eminem. They want it for a simple reason, those people are all famous glamourous millionaires. I swear, if the kids in my neighborhood were spend as much time studying science and math as hard as they do playing and practicing sports, we’d mint a whole slew of stud engineers. Yet the fact is, they would rather spend all their time playing sports, because they see sports as the path to greatness, not engineering.</p>
<p>Even of those people who realize that becoming the next great rapper or great athlete is not in the cards, a lot of them would still rather do something else besides engineering. Even many people who get engineering degrees don’t really want to be engineers. I believe the top employer of graduating engineers at MIT this year was not an engineering company. It was McKinsey, the management consulting company. A large chunk of the engineers at MIT are running off to consulting and banking, and even of those who aren’t, a lot of them wanted to take such jobs but couldn’t get an offer, so they have to ‘settle’ for engineering jobs because they couldn’t get what they really wanted. This ain’t some scrub no-name engineering school we’re talking about here - this is MIT. This is the best engineering school in the country, and we have all these engineering students who’d rather not be engineers. Nor is this peculiar to MIT. I know at the other top engineering schools like Stanford, Berkeley, Cornell, Michigan and the like - there are also plenty of engineers running off to consulting, banking, or other glamorous non-engineering jobs. These are the best engineering students in the country - some of the best human capital we got - and even many of them don’t want to work as engineers. </p>
<p>Why is that? Simple. More money, more prestige, more glamour, basically more of what they’re looking for in consulting or banking than they would get in engineering. One MIT engineering graduate who is joining McKinsey put it simply. At McKinsey, he will make more money than he would as an engineer. He will get to travel around the world, which is something he wants to do. And, perhaps most importantly, as he pointed out, he knows that the McKinsey name looks good on the resume. </p>
<p>What sickens me the most is when US business leaders pontificate about how the US needs to produce more engineers and more scientists, yet they refuse to improve the work conditions and compensation of the engineers. It doesn’t work that way. As long as engineering companies are unwilling to belly up to the bar and make offers to the engineers that are comparable to what the consulting companies and banks are offering, then you’re going to continue to have the best US talent leaving engineering. </p>
<p>The point is, I don’t think you can ‘push’ science/engineering knowledge onto the kids. It has to be a ‘pull’ mechanism. Kids will learn it only when they want to learn it, and the only way to get them to want to learn it is to improve the endgame incentives. Kids want to be LeBron James because they see him making millions on TV. MIT engineering students want to work as Wall Street bankers because they know that bankers make a lot of money. Basic economic principles dictate that people respond to incentives. The fewer incentives you give, the fewer people who are going to do what you want them to do.</p>