@MrAustere I wouldn’t let that acceptance rate sway you. The acceptance rates at all 4 schools are pretty low and even the higher ones, like northwestern’s, are artificially inflated by athlete recruitment for that Big 10 football team. ED should only be used on the school you genuinely want to attend the most. You don’t want to look back at your college years and wonder “hmm, would I have been happier at Johns Hopkins if I hadn’t applied ED to Northwestern?” If you are sure that Penn is your number 1 choice, then why not take advantage of the fact that the admissions office admits to looking more favorably upon ED applicants and take your chances? ED is everyone’s best chance to get into Penn-- it’s smart to apply early if you know there’s nowhere else you’d rather be. But if you aren’t sure if Penn is your number one, then for the same reasons, ED isn’t the right move. it sounds like you clearly have Penn as your first choice, however, and I thus recommend boosting your odds with ED
Good luck! Happy to answer any questions you have about Penn or top law school admissions from Penn. I know an ungodly amount about both Feel free to send me a message!
Also Top 15 is a super random cutoff just as a side note. Wash U in St Louis used to be top 15 but now this year it’s not. And Despite never being top 15, i don’t think anyone would consider Georgetown to be lesser than Wash U in any way, shape or form. If you are qualified to get into any of these schools ED, you’re qualified to get into them RD too. The odds are obviously less in your favor during RD because there are more applicants but if you are qualified and you apply broadly, you’ll probably get into a “Top 15-Caliber” school which definitely includes more than just those currently listed in the top 15.